Ed Bagley’s 2011 Final Top 25 Poll

Ed Bagley

What a year. College football in 2011 saw tons of scoring and very little defense. Only 1 undefeated team at the regular season’s end (LSU at 13-0). And for the first time ever, two teams from the same SEC West Division (#1 LSU and #2 Alabama) played for the BCS national championship.

Following is my Final Top 25 Poll for the 2011 season, and why I picked them the way that I did.

A couple of thoughts first. 1) All references to rankings in my poll are based on the Final AP Top 25 Poll and not the Coaches Poll or the BCS Standings. 2) In addition to won-loss records, I place a lot of importance on how teams played against other Top 25 teams during the regular season. 3) How did the team react under the bright lights, intense scrutiny, and pressure of their bowl game.

The fact that Houston, for example, ended the season at 13-1, had one opportunity to play a Top 25 team and lost against Southern Mississippi in the Conference USA championship game, and scored a big victory over an unranked Penn State team in its bowl game, does not impress me.

The fact that both the AP and Coaches Polls had Alabama #1, LSU #2, Oklahoma State #3, Oregon #4 and Arkansas #5 does not really influence me either.

Drum roll please.

1)  Alabama (12-1) – Fans can argue that Oklahoma State should have played LSU in the BCS title game, and the fact that the Cowboys had 3 victories against Top 25 teams before beating #7 Stanford in the Fiesta Bowl, but the Crimson Tide did lose to #1 LSU 9-6 in the regular season and sported an 11-1 record before meeting LSU for a second time. The point is, when given a second chance, Alabama shut out LSU 21-0 and made it darn clear who was the better team in the BCS title game. Oklahoma State may have run up 41 points on Stanford; it’s doubtful the Cowboys could have done the same against Alabama’s defense, which turned out to be the best in the nation in all 4 critical categories—rushing defense, passing defense, total defense and scoring defense.

2) LSU (13-1) – Is LSU the 2nd best team? I think this is also clear. The Tigers were the only undefeated team in the regular season that played 5 Top 25 teams and beat every one of them–#1 Alabama, #4 Oregon, #5 Arkansas, #17 West Virginia and #19 Georgia. No other team played and beat 4 Top 25 teams, and only two—Oklahoma State and Clemson—beat even 3 top teams during the regular season. LSU had a chance to go down as one of the greatest teams in NCAA history, but unfortunately, the Tigers really struggled in the BCS title game. LSU still had a sensational season by any other standard.

3) Oklahoma State (12-1) – The Cowboys only lost once, beat 3 Top 25 teams, and polished off #7 Stanford 41-38 in the Fiesta Bowl. While Oregon, Arkansas or Southern California could have been #3 on my list, each of these teams had only 1 win against other Top 25 teams.

4)  Arkansas (11-2) – The Razorbacks lost twice, to #1 Alabama and #2 LSU, and beat #15 Kansas State 29-16 in the Cotton Bowl. I doubt that either Oregon, Southern Cal or any other team would have fared any better against Alabama and LSU during regular season play.

5)  Oregon (12-2) – Oregon lost its first game of the season to LSU, and its second loss came against Southern Cal. The Ducks beat a physical Wisconsin team, 45-38, to win the Rose Bowl. Oregon’s no-huddle, hurry-up spread offense was something to watch. The Ducks also beat #7 Stanford on the road, 53-30.

6)  Michigan State (11-3) – Beat 2 Top 25 teams (#10 Wisconsin and #12 Michigan), and took down SEC’s Georgia 33-30 in the Outback Bowl. The Spartans had the 6th best total defense in the nation. No other team had at least 2 big wins against better competition, and that includes Southern Cal, Stanford, Boise State, South Carolina, Wisconsin, Michigan and Baylor to name a few.

7)  South Carolina (11-3) – Beat 2 Top 25 teams and polished off #24 Nebraska 30-13 in the Capital One Bowl. Can’t put Southern Cal, Stanford or Boise State ahead of the Gamecocks because none of these teams had 2 wins against Top 25 teams, USC did not play a bowl game because of NCAA sanctions, Stanford lost its bowl game to Oklahoma State, and all Boise State could do was beat an unranked, mediocre Arizona State team in the Maaco Bowl.

8)  Wisconsin (11-3) – Beat 2 Top 25 teams, and did lose to #4 Oregon in the Rose Bowl, but only by a touchdown, 38-45. The Badgers lost to Michigan State during the regular season, but did beat the Spartans for the Big Ten title.

9)  Stanford (11-2) – Beat only 1 Top 25 team (#6 Southern Cal 56-48 in overtime), and did lose to Oklahoma State in the Fiesta Bowl, but only by a field goal, 41-38.

10)  Southern California (10-2) – Beat only 1 Top 25 team (#4 Oregon on the road 38-35), and was not eligible for a bowl because of NCAA sanctions. Should have played Oregon for the Pacific 12 Conference title, but was not eligible for that game either. At the end of the year, no one wanted to play USC, and for good reason—the Trojans may well have beaten any team in the country except Alabama or LSU.

11)  Michigan (11-2) – The Wolverines turned out to be one of the biggest surprises of the season. They were 7-6 last year and won 11 games this year, including 1 win over a Top 25 team (Nebraska), and a 23-20 Sugar Bowl victory over #21 Virginia Tech.

12)  Baylor (10-3) – The Bears had 2 wins over Top 25 teams (TCU and Oklahoma) and outlasted unranked Washington, 67-56, in the Alamo Bowl. Baylor, like Oregon, was all offense, led by the 2011 Heisman Trophy winner, Robert Griffin III (or RG3). Baylor had losses to Kansas State and Oklahoma State, both ranked teams, which is more than Boise State can claim, having played only 1 ranked team all year.

13)  Boise State (12-1) – Had 1 win over a Top 25 team and a 56-24 win over unranked Arizona State in the Maaco Bowl.

14)  Oklahoma (10-3) – The Sooners had 2 wins over Top 25 teams, and beat unranked Iowa 31-14 in the Insight Bowl.

15)  Southern Mississippi (12-2) – Beat #18 Houston, 49-28, for the Conference USA title, and then beat unranked Nevada, 24-17, in the Hawaii Bowl.

16)  Georgia (10-4) – Lost to Boise State, South Carolina and to LSU in the SEC championship game. Then lost to Michigan State in the Outback Bowl, but only by a field goal, 33-30.

17)  Nebraska (9-4) – Lost to Wisconsin, Northwestern and Michigan, beat Michigan State at home, and lost 13-30 to South Carolina in the Capital One Bowl.

18)  TCU (11-2) – Upset #8 Boise State and beat unranked Louisiana Tech by a touchdown, 31-24, in the Poinsettia Bowl.

19)  Kansas State (10-3) – Beat Baylor, but lost to Arkansas 16-29 in the Cotton Bowl.

20)  West Virginia (10-3) – Beat 1 Top 25 team, and clobbered #22 Clemson, 70-33, in the Orange Bowl.

21)  Virginia Tech (11-3) – One of 5 teams that did not beat a single team in the final AP Top 25 Poll. The others were Georgia, Houston, Florida State and Cincinnati. Lost to Michigan in the Sugar Bowl, but only by a field goal, 20-23.

22)  Houston (13-1) – Could not beat a Top 25 team, but did beat unranked Penn State 30-14 in  the TicketCity Bowl. Houston, with 13 wins, is a modest team with great stats, and much to be modest about.

23)  Florida State (9-4) – Could not beat a Top 25 team, but did beat unranked Notre Dame 18-14 in the Champs Sports Bowl after the Irish blew a 14-point lead.

24)  Cincinnati (10-3) – Could not beat a Top 25 team, but did beat unranked Vanderbilt 31-24 in the Liberty Bowl (please, stop laughing).

25)  Clemson (10-4) – The Tigers did beat 3 Top 25 teams during the regular season (including Virginia Tech twice), but lost to West Virginia 33-70 in the Orange Bowl.  Yikes, what an ending to Clemson’s season of hope.

I would be the first to admit that my last 8 picks are not really top caliber teams. You could argue that none of them should be in a Top 25 list of really good teams. However, it is a Top 25 list that I am picking. Maybe the caliber of teams will be better next year. If any of them learn how to play defense, that would be a start to improvement.

For complete coverage of the 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2010 NCAA college football seasons, go to:

http://ed-bagley-blog-archives.com
 

2011 College Bowl Wrap-Up on All 35 Games

Copyright © 2011 and 2012 Ed Bagley

National Championship Game:

Alabama’s Defense Stifles and Then Snuffs Out LSU 21-Zip as the Crimson Tide Win Their 2nd BCS Title in 3 Years

The first football coach who declared that “defense wins championships” realized that his opponent could not score if his defense kept them off the field. That first coach was not Nick Saban of Alabama, but Saban was listening intently when he first heard it said, and the evidence of that was the 2011 BCS national championship game.

Alabama’s defense held LSU’s offense to 92 total yards and 5 first downs, no touchdowns and no field goals while getting 4 sacks, an interception and a fumble recovery—that’s an average gain of 2.09 yards on 44 attempts by LSU.

Did I mention that #2-ranked Alabama beat #1-ranked LSU 21-0, posting the first shutout in the 14-year history of the BCS playoff system. It was Alabama’s 2nd national championship in 3 years, and Nick Saban became the first coach to win 3 BCS national championships, and became the only active coach with 3 national titles.

Saban led LSU to the title in 2003, and Alabama in 2009. His lifetime record is 146-54 (73%).

LSU had beaten 8 ranked teams on its way to a perfect 13-0 mark on its way to the BCS title game, including Alabama 9-6 in a defensive struggle during the regular season. The Tigers’ offense did not show up for the title game because the Crimson Tide defense did not let them—that’s what a defense can do in a national championship game.

Jeremy Shelley tied a bowl record with 5 field goals, and Trent Richardson finally scored a touchdown with 4:36 remaining in the 4th quarter to really put the game away. Richardson gained 96 yards on 20 carries (4.8 YPC).

The Tide’s AJ McCarron was the offensive MVP, completing 23 of 34 passes (67%) for 234 yards and no interceptions. ‘Bama’s Courtney Upshaw as the defensive MVP; he had 7 tackles, a sack and spent most of his night in the LSU backfield. Upshaw was joined by Dont’a Hightower, both linebackers, in stopping both LSU’s running and passing game.

So, in a game that started with the betting line even, Alabama (12-1) beat LSU (13-1) by 21 points for the national title. Alabama was also No. 1 in both the final BCS Poll and AP Top 25 Poll. 

GoDaddy.com Bowl:

Northern Illinois, Down 13-Zip, Scores 31 Unanswered Points to Wipe Out Arkansas State, 38-20

The Northern Illinois Huskies know how to put together a winning streak, and they know how to come from behind to win. They proved it against Arkansas State by trailing 13-zip and then rattling off 31 unanswered points to win, 38-20, behind a gimpy quarterback and a receiver who had a career game.

Northern Illinois QB Chandler Harnish, playing with a bum ankle, connected 8 times with senior receiver Martel Moore for 224 yards (28.0 YPC), including a 43-yard touchdown pass. The Husky victory was the 9th straight for the Mid-American Conference (MAC) champions, and the loss by Arkansas State, the Sun Belt champions, snapped its 9-game winning streak. The Red Devils got going early, but could not overcome 5 turnovers, including 3 interceptions thrown by Ryan Aplin.

Despite the hurt ankle that took him out of the game at one point, Harnish went 18-of-36 (50%) for 274 yards and 2 touchdowns. He came in as the nation’s top rushing quarterback, averaging 106 yards per game, but was limited to minus 3 yards on the ground.

The victory marked the 3rd time this year that Northern Illinois coach Dave Doeren’s team has rallied from a double-digit deficit to win, a sign of a championship team.

Arkansas State was coached by David Gunn, who took over in an interim role after Hugh Freeze headed out of town for Mississippi. Both Freeze and the Red Wovles’ new coach—former Auburn offensive coordinator Gus Malzahn—watched the game from a press box, but were powerless to help as Northern Illinois rallied to win.

Compass Bowl:

Southern Methodist Scores 21 First-Quarter Points and Routs a Pathetic Pittsburgh Team, 28-6

The Southern Methodist University Mustangs have not lost this season when they score first or put up at least 21 points, and they put up 21 in the 1st quarter against a snakebitten and disheartened Pittsburgh team to rout the Panthers, 28-6. The Pitt effort in this game was pathetic.

The Mustangs gave coach June Jones his 100th collegiate win, and tied a school record by playing in their 3rd straight bowl game under Jones. Before June Jones left a tremendous record of success at Hawaii to coach at SMU, the Mustangs had not been in a postseason game since beating Notre Dame in the 1984 Aloha Bowl.

Mustang QB J.J. McDermott completed 16 of 26 passes (61%) for 239 yards and a touchdown as well as running another score, Darius Johnson caught 7 passes for 120 yards (17.1 YPC), including a 50-yard score, and Rishaad Wimbley hit paydirt twice for the Mustangs.

The Panthers were coached by defensive coordinator Keith Patterson, who took over after Todd Graham left to coach at Arizona State. It was Patterson’s last game before he starts his new job as the defensive coordinator at Arkansas State. Pittsburgh’s new coach, former Wisconsin offensive coordinator Paul Chryst, watched the game from the press box level.

Pitt never quite reached the top tier when former alum Dave Wannstadt was drop-kicked out of the program, and the Panthers have gone downhill since.

Southern Methodist (8-5), a dog by 4.5, beat Pittsburgh (6-7), by 22 points, proving that Pitt never should have won, must less have even been in a bowl game. When will this madness stop? This was the 33rd of this year’s 35 bowl games, which is at least 16 too many bowl games for a sane person.

Cotton Bowl:

Joe Adams and Tyler Wilson Lead the Arkansas Razorbacks Over Kansas State, 29-16

Arkansas star Joe Adams exploded for a 51-punt return, and All-SEC quarterback Tyler Wilson added 2 touchdown passes as the 7th-ranked Razorbacks rolled over the 11th-ranked Kansas State Wildcats, 29-16. Adams score was the first punt return for a touchdown in the 51-year history of the Cotton Bowl. He matched the SEC single-season record with his 4 punt return TDs this year, and was the only Division 1 (FBS) player this season with multiple punts returns for TDs, along with rushing and receiving scores.

The Razorbacks matched a school record with their 11th victory. Their only losses were to #1 LSU and #2 Alabama, their SEC West rivals who will play for the BCS national championship game. The only other 11-win seasons for the Razorbacks were by the Lou Holtz-coached team in 1977, and coach Frank Broyles’ only undefeated season at Arkansas in 1964.

Interestingly enough, a member of that 1964 team that won the Cotton Bowl over Nebraska was Jerry Jones, the Dallas Cowboys owner who attended this year’s game in his new $1.2 billion stadium (home of the Dallas Cowboys in Arlington, TX) that opened in 2009.

Kansas State won 11 games six times during a 7-year span in coach Bill Snyder’s first tenure before his 3-year retirement, and almost reached that mark in his 3rd season back this year. Wildcat QB Collin Klein tied the Big 12 record with his 27th rushing TD this season in a losing cause, and matched the FBS record for quarterbacks.

Arkansas (11-2), favored by 7.5, beat Kansas State (10-3) by 13—the Razorback betters went home twice as happy.

Orange Bowl:

Geno Smith Throws 6 TDs as West Virginia Eclipses Clemson, 70-33, and Teammate Tavon Austin Grabs 4 TD Passes

The 23rd-ranked West Virginia Mountaineers exploded on the 14th-ranked Clemson Tigers, scoring 5 touchdowns in the 2nd quarter to lead 49-20 at the half before eclipsing Clemson, 70-33, in record-setting style.

Mountaineer Geno Smith tied the record for any bowl game with 6 touchdown passes, and teammate Tavon Austin tied a record for any bowl game with 4 touchdown catches as West Virginia set a bowl-scoring record (70 points) with its high-powered offense.

Things really got rolling when safety Darwin Cook intervened. Clemson was on the verge of crawling back into the game in the 2nd quarter as Andre Ellington was 1 yard from scoring and apparently was stopped but not down when the ball came loose. Cook scooped it up and dashed 99 yards to score with nothing but clear field ahead of him.

Smith would complete 31 of 42 passes (74%) for 401 yards, breaking Tom Brady’s Orange Bowl record. Austin caught 11 passes for 117 yards (10.6 YPC). The win by West Virginia improved its BCS game record to 3-0. Clemson lost playing its first major bowl game in 30 years.

West Virginia (10-3 and ranked 23rd), a 3.5-point dog, beat Clemson (10-4 and ranked 14th) by 37 points. You would have done well to bet on West Virginia in this one—the Clemson Tigers turned out to be pussycats.  

Sugar Bowl:

First-Year Coach Brady Hoke Leads Michigan to an 11-2 Record and 23-20 BCS Sugar Bowl Win Over Virginia Tech in Overtime

If there is anyone who thinks Brady Hoke is not a good first-year coach for Michigan, no one is listening in Ann Arbor, home of the proud Wolverines. In a incredible turnaround, Hoke has lifted Michigan from mediocrity to an 11-2 record and a BCS Sugar Bowl victory over Virginia Tech, 23-20.

Michigan’s star QB Denard Robinson had an unspectacular night, game MVP Junior Hemingway caught 37 and 43-yard touchdown passes from Robinson, and Brenden Gibbons drilled a 37-yard field goal in overtime to lift the 13th-ranked Wolverines over the 17th-ranked Virginia Tech Hokies.

Tech’s senior receiver Danny Coale, who ranks 2nd all-time for the Hokies in catches and yards received, had 8 receptions for 117 yards in a losing cause, and nearly made a spectacular diving catch for a touchdown in overtime. Coale held on to the ball for what was initially ruled a score, but the play was overturned on video review, which showed the receiver had not maintained control of the ball when he hit the ground on the sideline.

Michigan followed up on its possession by using three conservative runs to set up Gibbons in the middle of the field, and then he drilled the winning kick. Virginia Tech kicker Justin Myer, a 3rd-stringer, had 4 good field goal attempts during the game for 37, 43, 36 and 25 yards, but was unable to connect from 37 yards out in overtime.

This year’s Wolverine team became only the 5th team in Michigan’s storied history to win 11 games in a season. Michigan (11-2 and ranked 13th), favored by 3, won by 3 over Virginia Tech (11-3 and ranked 17th), creating a push on the betting line.

Fiesta Bowl:

Oklahoma State Survives a Missed FG in Regulation to Win in Overtime Against Stanford, 41-38, Behind Brandon Weeden and Justin Blackmon

Surviving a missed field goal at the end of regulation play and getting a big kick of its own in overtime, 3rd-ranked Oklahoma State opened the door for a chance at a split national championship with a comeback offensive show for a 41-38 victory over 4th-ranked Stanford.

The Okie-State Cowboys kept pace with Stanford’s outstanding QB Andrew Luck, getting huge performances from their two stars, quarterback Brandon Weeden and the nation’s best wide receiver, Justin Blackmon.

Weeden threw for 399 yards and 3 touchdowns to Blackmon for 43, 67 and 17 yards. Blackmon, who announced after the game that he was leaving for the NFL, caught 8 passes for 186 yards (23.2 YPC).

In the end, the game rode on the leg and accuracy of the two place-kickers, Stanford’s Jordan Williamson and Oklahoma State’s Quinn Sharp. Williamson, a redshirt freshman under extreme pressure, could not come through, costing Stanford the game. Williamson missed a 35-yard field goal as regulation time expired, and then blew another from 43 yards to open the overtime period.

Quinn Sharp delivered. Given a chip shot after Weeden hit Colton Chelf on a 24-yard pass–initially ruled a touchdown but overturned on review–Sharp came though, sending his 22-yard field goal through the uprights and on to glory as the Cowboys swarmed the field in an exuberant display of joy and relief.

Jordan Williamson is not the first redshirt freshman to cost his team a bowl victory in an important game. If he is smart, he will forgive himself for being human, forget it, work on his accuracy and confidence in similar situations, and go on to become a great place-kicker for Stanford, perhaps even setting records. And, if Stanford is worth its salt as a college football team, they will give him the opportunity to do so.

Andrew Luck was Andrew Luck, completing 27 of 31 passes (87%) for 347 yards for 2 touchdowns. Luck, was has as much class as NFL talent, let the world know that if was not just about Williamson, that Stanford had a lot of chances to win prior to Williamson’s ill-fated kick. Good for Luck, he understands that the Stanford defense gave up 412 yards and 41 points to Oklahoma State.

Oklahoma State (12-1), favored by 3.5, won by 3 against Stanford (11-2), and did not cover the betting line.

Rose Bowl:

Oregon Outscores Wisconsin 10-Zip in the Last Quarter to Win Its First Rose Bowl in 95 Years, 45-38

In the end, Oregon’s frenzied, hurry-up, no-huddle spread offense wore down Wisconsin’s big, lumbering defensive linemen as the Ducks outlasted the Badgers, 45-38, in the highest-scoring Rose Bowl game in history.

Junior Darron Thomas passed for 3 touchdowns, true freshman De’Anthony Thomas (no relation) scored on runs of 91 and 64 yards, and the 6th-ranked Ducks earned their first bowl victory under coach Chip Kelly. The win was Oregon’s first Rose Bowl victory in 95 years, the last coming in 1917 when the Ducks shut out Penn State 14-zip.

The Ducks just pounded the Badgers with 621 yards of offense–345 yards rushing (8.63 YPC) and 276 passing.

LaMichael James rushed for 159 yards on 25 carries (6.36 YPC) and scored a touchdown. De’Anthony Thomas rushed for 155 yards on just 2 carries (77.5 YPC) and scored 2 touchdowns. James has blinding speed and Thomas may be even faster in the open field (Thomas is a world-class 200-meter athlete). Thomas may have cheetah speed–you can call him De’Anthony “Cheetah” Thomas (like, I cheeta you by 3 strides from midfield to the end zone, and that’s with a FAST defensive cornerback).

So how good was Oregon’s defense when it counted? Well, Wisconsin’s Montee Bell rushed for 122 of this 164 yards in the first half, but was held to zero yards on 3 carries in the 4th quarter.

Wisconsin’s Russell Wilson was able to move the Badgers to the Oregon 25-yard line but with 2 seconds left and no timeouts, he spiked the ball after time expired. It was a dumb play by a veteran quarterback under pressure. Wilson should have known that it takes about 3 seconds to spike the ball rather than throw a pass after the official starts the clock. Wilson will have to learn that lesson in the pros as his career at Wisconsin is over.

Both teams won their respective conferences’ first-ever league title games to earn the right to play in the BCS Rose Bowl. Oregon defeated a crummy UCLA team for the Pacific 12 Conference championship because Southern California could not play a bowl game this year due to NCAA sanctions. Wisconsin beat Michigan State for the Big Ten Conference title.

Oregon (12-2), favored by 6, won by 7 over Wisconsin (11-3), to cover the betting line.

Capital One Bowl:

Steve Spurrier and His Gamecocks Dump Bo (I Like to Whine) Pelini and His Nebraska Cornhuskers on Their Butt, 30-13

Steve Spurrier is building a winner at South Carolina. Despite kicking his star quarterback (Stephen Garcia) off the team, losing his star running back (Marcus Lattimore) to a season-ending injury, and undergoing an NCAA investigation for improper benefits, Spurrier and his Gamecocks kicked the snot out Nebraska, 30-13, when it counted.

They did it with Alshon Jeffery catching 4 passes for 148 yards and touchdown before getting ejected for fighting Nebraska cornerback Alfonso Dennard late in the 3rd quarter. Jeffery was called for a personal foul penalty, and then let Dennard know that he was damn serious by trading punches with him. It was only a few weeks ago that Jeffrey had surgery on his hand for an injury he received in the regular season’s final game.

Connor Shaw, who took over for Garcia after Spurrier had had enough and drop-kicked Garcia off the team, came up big when it counted, passing for 2 scores and rushing to another. He was 11-for-17 (65%) for 230 yards.

Nebraska coach Bo Pelini was running his mouth after the game about how his team was better than South Carolina–this is why a lot of people think Pelini is a jerk. We are not sure what game Pelini was watching since South Carolina had more offensive yards, was better on 3rd down, better on 4th down, did not turn the ball over, had fewer penalties for less yards, and won the frickin’ game by a 17-point margin.

Word on the street was that Bo Pelini returned to Nebraska as the same classless jerk as when he arrived at the Capital One Bowl.

How sweet was the victory for Spurrier and his Gamecocks? I’m glad you asked. It was this sweet: the 2011 South Carolina team was the first in Gamecock history to win 11 games in a season.

South Carolina (11-2 and ranked 10th), favored by 3, won by 17 over Nebraska (9-4 and ranked 21st), covering the betting line.

Outback Bowl:

In the 3rd Overtime, Georgia’s Blair Walsh Misses Critical Field Goal, and Michigan State’s Dan Conroy Does Not, and the Spartans Upset the Bulldogs, 33-30, to Win Their 11th Game for the Second Straight Season

Every team with double-digit victories needs a good place-kicker to show up when the crucial kick in an important bowl game needs to happen to win. Michigan State had one in the Outback Bowl and Georgia did not, so the Spartans ended up beating the Bulldogs, 33-30, during the 3rd overtime period.

Down a touchdown with less than 2 minutes left to play and 85 yards to go in regulation time, senior Kirk Cousins led his best drive of the day, and 10 plays later Michigan State’s power back Le’Veon Bell scored his 2nd touchdown of the day on a 1-yard run to tie it up at 27-all with 14 seconds left, sending the game into overtime.

Neither team scored in the 1st overtime that set the stage for a huge misfire by Georgia’s Blair Walsh, who missed a 42-yard field goal attempt that could have won the game for the Bulldogs. Walsh became the Southeastern Conference’s career scoring leader (412 points) with a 47-yard field goal in the 2nd overtime, matching a 35-yarder by Dan Conroy of the Spartans.

Conroy made a 28-yard field goal as Michigan State took the lead in the 3rd overtime. Blair was not so fortunate, his 47-yard attempt was blocked by Spartan defensive tackle Anthony Rashad White on the final play of the game.

Kirk Cousins was not at his best, completing 27 of 50 passes (a very subpar 54%) for 300 yards while throwing 3 interceptions. Cousins did leave Michigan State as the winningest quarterback in school history with 27 victories as a starter, and the 37 wins for the outgoing senior class was a school record as well.

Spartan receiver Brian Linthicum did much better, catching 7 passes for 115 yards (16.4 YPC) and a critical 2-point conversion.

Michigan State was terrible in the first half as the Bulldogs held them to only 2 first downs and just 72 yards of total offense while taking a 16-0 lead. The Spartans were really stinking up the field, and boosters were wondering if they were going to see a repeat of last year, when Michigan State was beat 49-7 by Alabama in the Capital One Bowl.

The win ended a 5-game losing streak for Michigan State and 4-game losing streak for coach Mark Dantonio. Maybe Dantonio got excited enough to smack some players up side the head with a 2X4. In any event, the Spartans outscored Georgia 27-11 to tie it up and win in overtime.

Dantonio put his spin on the game, saying it was a “big win against a great football team, against an SEC team, against a team that won their division and that was 10-2 in the regular season . . . There’s not a football team that we cannot play with and not win against. We’ve done that.”

Then Dantonio added this: “Two 11-win seasons. There’s not too many football teams in the country that are saying that right now. I would think that this, hopefully, helps solidify a top 10 ranking in this year’s final polls.” Give Dantonio some props–he got ripped a new one against Alabama last year, and ended up on top this year.

Georgia’s Mr. Everything–Brandon Boykin–was everywhere making great plays in the Bulldogs losing effort. Boykin was there when Michigan State started the game in fit of ineptitude. Boykin tackled Keshawn Martin in the end zone for a safety on Michigan State’s first offensive play, converging on the receiver at almost the same time as Cousins’ side screen.

This made Martin look bad when it was one of the most awful calls–considering the Spartans were all but on their goal line to start the game–ever made by an offensive coordinator that I have seen in more than 50 years of watching college football. The Spartans had a power back–Le’Veon Bell–and were damn lucky to get smart enough to use him to tie the game up in regulation time.

Why Bell was not used more in the game was beyond me. Cousins was so bad throwing that he could have easily lost the game for Michigan State.

Back to Boykin. After getting the safety for Georgia, he returned a punt 92 yards for a lights-out touchdown, and caught a 13-yard touchdown pass that helped the Bulldogs take a late lead that one of the nation’s stingiest defenses could not protect down the stretch, but only because their field goal kicker missed when he could have converted in overtime.

Both teams entered the game coming off losses in their conference championship games. Michigan State won the Legends Division title and then lost the Big Ten title to Wisconsin, 42-39. Wisconsin went on to lose 45-38 to Oregon in the Rose Bowl. Georgia won the East Division title and then lost the Southeastern Conference title to Louisiana State, 42-10.

Michigan State (11-3 and ranked 12th), a 3.5-point dog, beat Georgia (10-4 and ranked 18th), by 3, and you have to believe Michigan State fans and boosters who laid money on the Spartans were happy, as well they should be.

Gator Bowl:

Florida’s Gators Use Their Speed, Defense and Special Teams Play to Dump Ohio State, 24-17

First-year coach Will Muschamp and his Florida Gators used their defense and special teams play to beat Ohio State, 24-17. Six sacks, a 99-yard kickoff return for a score by Andre Debose, and a blocked punt by Chris Rainey that was returned for another score did the trick. Florida simply had much more speed than the Buckeyes.

Some Florida players took out their frustration at Urban Meyer in the game. Meyer left Florida and now is the new head coach who will start at Ohio State in the fall. Muschamp was the former defensive coordinator at Texas before replacing Meyer.

The win helped the Gators (7-6) avoid their first losing season since 1979, and Ohio State (6-7) finished below .500 for the first time since 1988. Both of these big time football programs were a shadow this year of what they have been in recent years.

Florida, favored by 2, won by 7 over Ohio State, to cover the betting line.

TicketCity Bowl:

Case Keenum Passes for 532 Yards and 3 Touchdowns as Houston Rolls Past Penn State, 30-14

Case Keenum and his Cougars earned Houston’s first ever 13-win season by showing Penn State’s best nothing but taillights in the TicketCity Bowl, rolling up 532 yards passing and 3 touchdowns by Keenum to beat the Nittany Lions, 30-14. Keenum’s quick release and Houston’s no-huddle attack left the Nittany Lions in the dust.

Penn State had no chance in this one. The 24th-ranked Nittany Lions, who were giving up 162 passing yards per game, were torched by Cougar QB Keenum, who threw for more than double that by halftime. Keenum finished the day by completing 45 of 69 passes (65%), 2 fewer attempts than the number of offensive plays run by Penn State.

Houston was ranked 20th coming into game, and would have been ranked higher but was upset 49-28 by Southern Mississippi in the Conference USA title game.

Longtime Penn State coach Joe Paterno was axed during the season amid mounting criticism that school leaders should have done more to prevent the shocking abuse allegations against retired assistant Jerry Sandusky.

Houston (13-1), favored by 6, won by 16 over Penn State (9-4) to cover the betting line.

Chick-fil-A Bowl:

Despite Losing Newton and Dyer, and Its Defensive Coordinator, Auburn Tops Virginia Behind the Running of Onterio McCalebb, 43-24

When Auburn went undefeated at 14-0 last year and won the national championship, but lost its star quarterback, leader and Heisman Trophy-winner Cam Newton to the NFL, people wondered how Auburn would do this season.

When Auburn went 7-5 in the regular season, absorbing tough losses to LSU, Georgia and Alabama, and then losing star running back Mike Dyer, who was suspended for an undisclosed rules violation, people wondered how Auburn would do in its bowl game against Virginia. After the Alabama loss, defensive coordinator Ted Roof also left for the same position at Central Florida.

The solution for Auburn turned out to be Onterio McCalebb, who decided to make a difference when he replaced Mike Dyer. McCalebb rushed for 109 yards on 10 carries (10.9 YPC) and scored a touchdown to lead Auburn over Virginia, 43-24. The Tiger defense blocked 2 punts and recovered an onside kick.

Auburn piled up 273 yards against Virginia, and needed to when starting QB Clint Moseley limped off the field with an injured right ankle after Auburn’s second possession. He did not return, and was replaced by Barrett Trotter, who passed for 175 yards and a touchdown while sharing time with Kiehl Frazier, who added 2 rushing touchdowns.

The 43-point output was Auburn’s highest of the year for offensive coordinator Gus Malzahn, who will take over as head coach at Arkansas State next season. As offensive coordinator when Auburn won the national title last year, Malzahn won the Broyles Award as the top assistant coach in college football.

Auburn (8-5), favored by 1.5, won by 19 over Virginia (also 8-5).

Liberty Bowl:

Isaiah Pead Gains 149 Yards to Lead Underdog Cincinnati’s 31-24 Upset Victory Over Vanderbilt

Isaiah Pead ran for 149 yards and a touchdown, and Ralph David Abernathy IV (that’s his name, folks) returned a kickoff 90 yards to score early in the 4th quarter to put Cincinnati ahead to stay as the Bearcats edged Vanderbilt, 31-24. Pead became the game’s MVP.

The Vandy Commodores led 21-17 when Abernathy became the first Cincinnati player to return a kickoff for a TD in the program’s 13 bowl appearances. In an example of making the most of your opportunity, Cincy’s George Winn scored on a 69-yard run when he replaced Pead, while the Big East Offensive Player of the Year fixed a broken chin strap.

Cincinnati (10-3), a 3-point dog coming in, won by 7 over Vanderbilt (6-7)—the oddsmakers really blew this call. Cincinnati was the co-Big East Conference champions, and Vanderbilt finished in a tie for 4th in the SEC’s East Division.

Fight Hunger Bowl:

In a Battle of Two Mediocre 6-6 Teams, Illinois Gets By UCLA, 20-14, After Both Coaches Are Fired Before the Bowl Game Begins

Wow, what a mess the Fight Hunger Bowl was—two stinking, mediocre teams, so bad that both coaches were fired before the season ended. In this setting, Illinois topped UCLA 20-14 with no highlights worth mentioning. In essence, Illinois was a fraud and UCLA was just plain, stinking bad.

Illinois started its season with 6 straight wins against inferior competition, then promptly lost to Ohio State, Purdue, Penn State, Michigan, Wisconsin and Minnesota, and then fired coach Ron Zook. Interim coach Vic Koenning won for Illinois. New coach Tim Beckman starts next season.

UCLA was bipolar, going through stretches of lose-win, lose-win, lose-win, lose-win and lose-win. No wonder coach Rick Neuheisel’s head was spinning faster than Daiwa fishing reel. Then his UCLA Bruins got to the Pacific 12 championship game with a mediocre 6-6 record because Southern California was ineligible due to NCAA sanctions for wrong-doing. Oregon promptly hammered them, 49-31, despite a Bruin effort to show better. Neuheisel, in his dream job as a UCLA grad and former Rose Bowl-winning Bruin quarterback, was let go.

Interim coach Mike Johnson lost for UCLA against Illinois. New coach Tim Beckman starts next season. Illinois (7-6), favored by 3 over UCLA (6-8), won by 6. At least the Illini fans and boosters who bet on the game got paid.

Sun Bowl:

Utah Ties Game on a Last Ditch, 4th-and-14 Play, and Then Beats Georgia Tech in Overtime, 30-27, on John White’s 8-Yard Power Run

Utah was down 24-10 at one point, but a 28-yard scoring pass from Jon Hays to DeVonte Christopher on a 4th-and-14 play with 1:32 left tied the game with Georgia Tech at 24-all. Georgia Tech would get a field goal lead in overtime, but John White’s 8-yard power run sealed the victory for Utah as the Utes downed the Yellow Jackets, 30-27.

Georgia Tech drove to the Utah 31 with 2 seconds left in regulation time, but missed a 48-yard field-goal attempt as time expired, sending the Sun Bowl into overtime for the first time in its 77-year history.

John While would finish with 115 yards on 26 carries (4.4 YPC) and the winning touchdown in OT. QB Jon Hayes went 15-for-31 (48%) for 193 yards and 3 touchdowns. Preston Lyons had 138 yards rushing on 18 carries (7.7 YPC) and one score for Georgia Tech.

Georgia Tech lost its 7th straight bowl appearance (ouch), and Utah improved to 7-1 in bowl games under coach Kyle Whittingham. Georgia Tech (8-5) was favored by 3.5 and lost by 3 to Utah (also 8-5).

Meineke Car Care Bowl:

Texas A&M Gets Its Game On to Hammer Northwestern, 33-22, and Honor Fired Coach Mike Sherman and Joey Villavisencio, Who Was Killed in a Car Accident

Let there by no doubt. Despite losing its last 5 bowl games, the Texas A&M Aggies got their game on to blast past Northwestern, 33-22, and honor fired coach Mike Sherman and Joey Villavisencio, who was killed in a tragic car accident a week before the game.

When Sherman got the axe, interim coach Tim DeRuyter wondered how the Aggies would respond to the adversity and a disappointing 6-6 regular season performance. He is no longer wondering, and now is on his way to become head coach at Fresno State. The Aggies hired former Houston coach Kevin Smith to take over for Sherman, but he wasn’t involved in the bowl game preparations.

Texas A&M got its winning boost from Ryan Tannehill, who threw for 329 yards and a touchdown, and Ben Malena, who ran for 2 more scores. After falling behind 7-3, the Aggies reeled off 27 straight points to take control of game.

Texas A&M (7-6), favored by 10, beat Northwestern (6-7) by 11 and made its loyal fans and boosters happy.

Insight Bowl:

Oklahoma Closes Out Its Disappointing Year With a Crappy 31-14 Win Over Iowa

Oklahoma, ranked #1 in the preseason, did not look good while beating Iowa, 31-14, in the Insight Bowl to end its season ranked 19th with a 10-3 record and poor performances from QB Landry Jones its rushing offense.

Iowa fell behind 21-zip after the 3rd quarter, but rallied for two touchdowns in the last quarter as the Sooners let up. Coach Bob Stoops thought his team played an “excellent” game—no one was sure what game Stoops was watching after making that comment.

Oklahoma’s chances of a national title run took a major hit with the injury of All-American receiver Ryan Broyles (a torn ACL) and two critical losses in its final 3 games, including a 44-10 rout by rival Oklahoma State in the Big 12 championship game. At Oklahoma, that’s called unacceptable. Every team has injuries to key players, but the loss of Broyles shows the lack of Sooner depth to make up the loss.

Oklahoma (10-3), favored by 14 in this mismatch (the biggest line of the bowl season), won by 17 over Iowa (7-6).

As a sign of Iowa’s season, an overhead camera crashed to the field during the closing minutes, just missing receiver Marvin McNutt, tangling him in the wire but not injuring him. The game was delayed 5 minutes for clean-up. It was as if Oklahoma’s enthusiasm was stifled once again in a disappointing season for the Sooners as well.

Music City Bowl:

Running Back Vick Ballard and the Mississippi State Defense Lead the Bulldogs Over Wake Forest, 23-17

The formula is as old as football—run the ball, play defense and win. Mississippi State did it to perfection as Vick Ballard picked up 180 yards on 14 carries (12.9 YPC) and scored twice, and the Bulldog defense racked up 6 sacks and successfully defended at the crucial moment to defeat Wake Forest, 23-17.

Ballard scored his touchdowns on 60-yard and 72-yard runs. The win was Mississippi State’s 5th straight in bowl-game action, and 2nd straight for coach Dan Mullen. You remember Dan Mullen, he’s the guy who has tutored several notable players, including quarterbacks Alex Smith at Utah, Josh Harris at Bowling Green, Chris Lead at Florida and Heisman Trophy-winner Tim Tebow at Florida, before becoming a head coach for the first time at Mississippi State.
 
Mississippi State (7-6), favored by 7, won by 6 and did not cover over Wake Forest (6-7).

Pinstripe Bowl:

Two Redshirt Freshmen Lead Rutgers Past Iowa State, 27-13, as Eric LeGrand Watches His Teammates Win One for Him

The Rutgers Scarlet Knights won one for Eric LeGrand, beating Iowa State 27-13 behind a couple of redshirt freshmen—Brandon Coleman (who hauled in an 86-yard touchdown pass in the 4th quarter), and Jawan Jamison (who ran for 131 yards and 2 touchdowns).

Eric LeGrand was watching the game from the press box, in a wheelchair after being paralyzed making a tackle for Rutgers more than a year ago. He is still very much part of the Rutgers football program, and is a positive presence and motivator in the Scarlet Knight locker room.

Armed Forces Bowl:

Fake Spike and Scoring Throw With 11 Seconds Left Gives Brigham Young a 24-21 Victory Over Tulsa

The call from coach Bronco Mendenhall was spike the ball to stop the clock, but Brigham Young quarterback had a better idea—he faked the spike and then threw his 3rd touchdown pass to Cody Hoffman with 11 seconds left to give the Cougars a 24-21 victory over Tulsa. The Tulsa Golden Hurricane players were totally surprised, and not ready to defend; it cost them the game.

Hoffman ended the game with 8 catches for 122 yards (15.2 YPC) and 3 touchdowns. To add insult to the wound of his game-winning catch, the Cougars had not practiced the “fake spike and throw” play for 2 months.

The win by Brigham Young gave the Cougars their 5th 10-win year in the last 7 seasons during coach Mendenhall’s tenure. During the recent game of musical chairs being played by teams changing conferences, Brigham Young opted to become a football independent this season after its departure from the Mountain West Conference.

Brigham Young (10-3), favored by 3, won by 3 over Tulsa (8-5) to create a push on the betting line.

Alamo Bowl:

In a Game for the History Books, Baylor Beats Washington, 67-56, as Both Teams Combine for 1,397 Yards of Offense, and Exactly Zero Defense

In the end, it looked like more points were scored at this year’s Alamo Bowl than shots fired in defense of the Alamo, but unlike the tragedy at the Alamo, this year’s event was far more exciting in a positive way despite the total lack of defense by both teams involved.

For the record, 15th-ranked Baylor (10-3) beat Washington (7-6), 67-56.

The 123 points scored was the highest-scoring regulation bowl game in history, breaking the record of 102 scored by Marshall and East Carolina in the 2001 GMAC Bowl.

The 1,397 yards of offense by Baylor (777) and Washington (620) also set the bowl game record.

Among the highlights:

Baylor scored 21 points in the 1st quarter, Washington scored 28 in the 2nd, and Baylor scored 29 in the 3rd quarter. Five plays covered 50 or more yards, and 3 were scores—an 80-yard pass from Keith Price to Jermaine Kearse for Washington, an 89-yard run by Terrance Ganaway for Baylor, and a 56-yard run by Chris Polk for Washington.

Baylor would have three 100-yard rushers—Terrance Ganaway got 200 yards on 21 carries (9.52 YPC) and scored 5 touchdowns, Jarred Salubi got 101 yards on 5 carries (20.2 YPC), and Tevin Reese picked up 101 yards on 2 carries (55.5 YPC). Washington’s Chris Polk gained 147 yards on 30 carries (4.9 YPC).

Washington’s sophomore quarterback—Keith Price—actually outplayed Robert Griffin III, Baylor’s all-world quarterback and this year’s Heisman Trophy winner as the Most Outstanding College Player.

RG 3 (not R2-D2), as the Baylor nation calls its Heisman winner, went 24-of-33 (72%) for 295 yards with 1 passing TD and 1 rushing TD.

Price was 23-of-37 (62%) for 438 yards with 4 passing touchdowns (including an 80-yarder), and 3 rushing touchdowns of 5, 8 and 15 yards. Price had a hand in 7 scoring touchdowns for Washington, which put 56 points on Baylor and still lost the game—an indictment of the Huskies pathetic defense, which was ranked 94th among 120 teams coming into the Holiday Bowl.

You can say that Baylor averaged 571 yards a game in the regular season, and NO ONE could stop the Bears offensive machine. And that’s true, as Baylor ranked 2nd in the nation in total offense.

How could Washington score 56 points and lose? Well, that’s an easy answer. What is overlooked about Baylor is its absolutely pathetic defense. Washington was ranked 94th, the Bears were ranked 114th among 120 teams. In other words, both teams had defenses that weren’t worth horseshit in a barnyard.

Knowing this does take some of the luster off of the exciting Holiday Bowl action, which at times looked like a gym-rat, run-and-dunk basketball game.

I gotta be honest. When Baylor went up 21-7 I figured the game was over for Washington. I switched the tube to another channel. When I came back to the game, Washington led 35-21 and I couldn’t believe my eyes. But, true to form, the better team did win in the end, 67-56, in a great offensive show with absolutely no defense worth mentioning.

So Baylor (10-3) was favored by 9 and won by 11 over Washington (7-6). I will say this: Baylor did not look like the 15th best team in the country in the Holiday Bowl, and Washington did not look like the 40th best team in the country.

Washington did play 4 ranked teams during the season and lost big time to each of them—Nebraska, Stanford, Oregon and Southern California. The Huskies held their own against Baylor, despite their 10-3 record.

I leave you with this obscure fact: How many teams with 8 wins or more in the regular season played a tougher schedule than the 24th-ranked Washington Huskies? Would you believe ONLY 7? They were LSU (17th), Alabama (22nd), Oklahoma State (6th), Oklahoma (5th), Baylor (7th), Southern California (20th) and Kansas State (10th).

Is Washington a team to watch next year? You figure it out, you’re bright enough.

Champs Sports Bowl:

Notre Dame Scores the First 14, Florida State Scores the Next 18 and Beats the Irish, 18-14

Notre Dame blew a 14-point lead, allowing Florida State to score the next 18 points in the game as the Seminoles put the Irish in their place, 18-14, to win the Champs Sports Bowl.

Timeout: About the Champs Sports Bowl name—seriously, a 4th grade sports fan could come up with a better name. They should have a contest to rename this bowl next year. The only worse name for a bowl game this year was the Belk Bowl—even if the name of that one was the Macy’s Bowl or Nordstrom Bowl, it still wouldn’t fit. This is a sports event, not a fashion show.

The Seminoles used a pair of touchdown passes from E. J. Manuel and two field goals from Dustin Hopkins to earn their 4th straight bowl win. Notre Dame held Florida State to 18 yards of total offense in the 1st half, and injuries forced the Seminoles to play 4 freshmen on their defensive line, which gave up 5 sacks. That said, Florida State’s defense got 3 picks and 4 sacks.

Brian Kelly, flush from success at Cincinnati when he arrived as head coach at Notre Dame, just cannot seem to get the Irish back to a national rep quickly. Kelly went 8-5 his first year and is stuck there again this year. Florida State (9-4) was favored by 3 and won by 4. The Seminoles were ranked 25th coming into the game.

Holiday Bowl:

Ho Hum Game Finds Texas Besting California, 21-10, With the Longhorn Defense Showing Best

The Bear may be Golden, but he appears to be no match against a Longhorn. The Texas Longhorns had 5 takeaways and 6 sacks against the California Golden Bears to win, 21-10. California is winless in 5 games against Texas dating to 1959, a 52-year drought.

The game itself may have been the most dull of the bowl season, deserving no offensive highlights. Texas (8-5) was favored by 3 and beat California (7-6) by 11. Texas was modest at best, with apparently much to be modest about. California was, California—the Bears get beat almost every year late in the season and, without much encouragement, have raised losing to an art form.

Military Bowl:

Air Force Ties the Game With 52 Seconds Left, and Then Botches a 2-Point Conversion as Toledo Wins By One, 42-41

In a game that matched 2 of the Top 25 scoring teams in the country, Toledo beat Air Force 42-41 when the Falcons were able to draw within a point of tie with 52 seconds left to play and then botched a 2-point conversion and lost.

Air Force had already scored 3 fourth-down touchdowns this year, and Matt Campbell, Toledo’s 32-year-old coach, and his staff had their team ready to make the stop when holder David Baska got bottled up trying to run the option. The ball squirted toward kicker Parker Herrington, who chased it until it went out of bounds in the end zone, giving Toledo its first bowl win since 2005.

Bernard Reedy’s 3rd touchdown of the game—a 37-yard catch, spin and run on a pass from Terrance Owens—gave the Rockets a 42-35 lead with 5:01 remaining. Reedy had 4 receptions for 126 yards (31.5 YPC) and 3 touchdowns. Owens, filling in for Austin Dantin who was out with a concussion, completed 19-of-24 passes (79%) for 210 yards and 3 TDs.

In the end, Air Force (7-6) was game, but Toledo took the hardware home. The Rockets (9-4) were favored by 3 and won a point, and in football, that’s all it takes—the rest is window dressing. 

Belk Bowl:

North Carolina State’s Tom O’Brien Believed in Mike Glennon, Who Led the Wolfpack Past Louisville, 31-24

North Carolina State coach Tom O’Brien took a lot of flak when he let star quarterback Russell Wilson loose and decided to go with unproven junior Mike Glennon. Wilson transferred to Wisconsin, giving the Badgers the star QB they needed to make a run at the national title.

Wilson did not disappoint. Wisconsin did not make it to the national championship game, but the Badgers will meet Oregon in the Rose Bowl. Now we know what O’Brien saw that Wolfpack fans and boosters did not.

Untested Mike Glennon went 21-of-33 (63%) for 264 yards and 3 touchdowns to lead North Carolina State to a 31-24 victory over Louisville in the Belk Bowl, earning MVP honors in the process. O’Brien, nobody’s fool, ran his record to 8-2 in bowl games.

Don’t even ask me what a Belk is. OK, already, all right now—I Googled it. Apparently a Belk is a “leading retail department store”—it just is not a nationwide chain at the moment so a lot of folks (like me) would not have a clue. Maybe that’s why they sponsor a bowl game, to get better known. I will become more of a believer when they expand to the Pacific Northwest.

Little Caesars Pizza Bowl:

Purdue Coach Danny Hope Opts for 2 Surprise Onside Kicks That Help Lift the Boilermakers Over Western Michigan, 37-32

Purdue coach Danny Hope threw caution to the wind by deciding to go for 2 surprise onside kicks in the first half and both gambles paid off for the Boilermakers in a 37-32 win against Western Michigan in the Little Caesars Pizza Bowl. Purdue kicker Carson Wiggs ran at full speed on both onside kick tries, but tapped the ball toward the sideline, recovering one of his kicks.

Raheem Mostert ran a kickoff back 99 yards to score, 3rd-string running back Reggie Pegram scored the first 2 touchdowns of his career, and Carson Wiggs made 2 field goals to give the Boilermakers a 27-15 halftime lead that they held. 

Western Michigan had a chance to go ahead, but Bronco QB Alex Carder fumbled for his 5th turnover of the game with just under 2 minutes left. The loss was Western Michigan’s 5th in postseason play without a win.

Purdue (7-6) was favored by 2 and won by 7 against Western Michigan (also 7-6), which had to make the Boilermaker boosters happy and richer.

Independence Bowl:

James Franklin Leads Missouri Past North Carolina, 41-24, in the Tigers Last Game in the Big 12 Conference

The Missouri Tigers made the most of their last game as a Big 12 Conference school, crushing the North Carolina Tar Heels, 41-24, in the Independence Bowl behind the rushing and passing of James Franklin.

Franklin, a 6-foot-2, 225-pound sophomore, ran for 142 yards in 18 carries (7.89 YPC) and scored twice on short runs, and went 15-of-23 (65%) through the air for 132 yards and a scoring pass.

Missouri (8-5), which led 31-10 at the half, was favored by 5 and won by 17 in a breeze. North Carolina’s Tar Heels (7-6) started its season at 5-1 and then lost 5 of their last 7 under interim coach Everett Withers, who leaves to become the defensive coordinator at Ohio State under Urban Meyer next year.

Missouri has now kissed the Big 12 goodbye and will play as a newcomer in the Southeastern Conference with the big boys next season. Let’s hope the Tigers are ready, because it they thought the Big 12 was tough, they have no idea what it is going to be like in the SEC.     

Hawaii Bowl:

Southern Mississippi Joins an Elite Group of Teams With 12 Wins by Stopping Nevada’s  Potent Pistol Attack, 24-17

If you had anything to do with the 22nd-ranked Southern Mississippi Golden Eagles at the Hawaii Bowl, you should have gone home happy for 7 reasons.

First, the SM signal-caller Austin Davis was anything but outstanding during the game, but got it together with the score tied at 17 on the game-winning drive, finding Kelvin Bolden in the end zone for a 4-yard score that gave the Golden Eagles a 24-17 victory over Nevada.

Second, the win followed an upset victory over then unbeaten Houston 49-28 to capture the Conference USA championship.

Third, the Hawaii Bowl win pushed the Golden Eagles record to 12-2 on the season, marking their first 12-win season ever, and their first 10-win season in 23 years (1988).

Fourth, coach Larry Fedora goes out a winner in his final game. He leaves SM after 4 years, taking a step up to become the new head coach at North Carolina in the Atlantic Coast Conference.

Fifth, the Golden Eagle defense got it together in the 2nd half as well. Nevada’s Lampford Mark, the key to the Wolf Pack’s potent pistol attack, gained 183 yards rushing on 29 carries (6.31 YPC) and scored 2 touchdowns, BUT was held to just 21 yards and no scores in the 2nd half.

Sixth, when Tray Becton-Martin recovered a fumble in the end zone following a blocked punt by Tim Green, he became the 25th different player to score for the Golden Eagles this season, an NCAA leading-statistic for a score by the most players on a team.

Seventh, boosters went home happy. Southern Mississippi (12-2), was favored by 6.5 and won by 7 over Nevada (7-6).

Maaco Las Vegas Bowl:

Boise State Destroys Arizona State, 56-24, as Kellen Moore Sets the NCAA Record for Wins by a Quarterback

It was seniors day for the Boise State Broncos at the Maaco Las Vegas Bowl against the Arizona State Sun Devils. The Broncos (12-1) led 28-3 at the half and won 56-24. They were favored by 14 and won by 32 as the Sun Devils (6-7) looked as bad as they are.

Running back Doug Martin returned the opening kickoff 100 yards for a touchdown, and then rushed for 151 yards on 31 carries (4.9 yards per carry) and scored another touchdown. Quarterback Kellen Moore went 26-of-34 (76%) for 293 yards and 2 touchdowns.

The win—his 50th—gave Kellen Moore the NCAA record for wins by a quarterback. If you are wondering, Colt McCoy of Texas had 45, and both David Greene of Georgia and Andy Dalton of TCU had 42.

Boise State finished 7th in the BCS standings, but wasn’t invited to one of its big-money bowl games. Entering the bowl game, Moore was completing 74% of his passes, racking up 3,507 yards and 41 touchdowns with just 7 interceptions. 

Poinsettia Bowl:

Two 4th Quarter Touchdowns Lift Texas Christian Over Lousisiana Tech, 31-24, as Casey Pachall Sets Records

Things did not look good for TCU when Louisiana Tech converted 2 Horned Frog turnovers into touchdowns to take a 24-17 lead after 3 quarters in the Poinsettia Bowl. So the Horned Frogs went to work and showed why they were a 10.5-point favorite and ranked #16 in the AP Top 25 Poll.

They held Louisiana Tech scoreless in the 4th quarter while scoring twice to win, 31-24. Casey Pachall found Skye Dawson on a 42-yard TD with 4:26 remaining to seal the victory. TCU (11-2), favored by 10.5, won by 7 over Louisiana Tech (8-5).

It was a big night for Pachall. He picked up a bowl game victory, and set school single-season records for completions (228), yards (2,921) and completion percentage (66.5), breaking marks previously held by Andy Dalton. You remember Andy Dalton, he’s now playing for the Cincinnati Bengals in the NFL.

The win was the 8th straight for Mountain West Champion TCU Horned Frogs, who will move to the Big 12 next year. The Poinsettia Bowl victory marked the 3rd time this season that TCU has come from behind in the last quarter to win, including a 36-35 victory at Boise State, the Broncos’ only regular season loss.

Beef ‘O’ Brady’s Bowl:

Freshman QB Leads Marshall’s Thundering Herd to a 20-10 Upset Win Over Florida International

A freshman quarterback and a blocked punt was all it took for Marshall to upset Florida International 20-10 in the Beef O’ Brady’s Bowl.

A 10-10 halftime tie was snapped with 5:16 left in the game when Tyler Warner’s 39-yard field goal followed a blocked punt by Zach Dunston that put the Thundering Herd up 13-10.

Freshman QB Rakeem Cato would later find Aaron Dobson on a 35-yard scoring pass to seal the victory, bringing Marshall’s 1-A bowl record to 7-2. Cato was 27-of-39 (69%) for 226 yards and another 31-yard scoring toss to Dobson.

Florida International (8-5), favored by 4, lost by 10. Marshall ‘s Thundering Herd (7-6) overcame a slow start to win 5 of their last 7 games and avoid a losing season in their second season under coach Doc Holliday.

New Orleans Bowl:

Last Second 50-Yard Field Goal Lifts Louisiana-Lafayette Over Favored San Diego State, 32-30

Let’s talk redemption—Louisiana-Lafayette’s Brett Baer, who missed 2 extra point attempts during the game, nailed a 50-yard field goal as time ran out, giving the Ragin’ Cajuns a dramatic 32-30 win over San Diego State in the New Orleans Bowl.

San Diego State had taken a 30-29 lead by scoring with 35 seconds left, and Brett Baer’s last ditch, 55-yard first attempt in the next series was no good when the Aztecs got caught on a pre-snap penalty trying to bait the Cajuns into a false start. The penalty moved Bear 5 yards closer, and he did not miss on his second attempt to win the game.

The kick became important because Cajun quarterback Blaine Gautier had a record-setting day, going 24-for-40 (60%) for 470 yards and 3 touchdowns, and receiver Javone Lawson caught 9 passes for 193 yards (21+ YPC) and 2 touchdowns. Gautier finished the season with 2,958 yards passing and 23 TDs, breaking Jake Delhomme’s single-season school records.

First-year coach Mark Hudspeth was ecstatic with the victory as the Cajuns were playing their first bowl game with the big boys as a Division 1 FBS team. Their last bowl game was 41 years ago. LA-Lafayette fans came out in droves, setting a New Orleans Bowl attendance record of 42,800+.

San Diego State (8-4), a 4.5 point favorite, lost by 2. LA-Lafayette finished at 9-4.

Famous Idaho Potato Bowl:

Ohio’s Bobcats Nip Utah State 24-23 in the Last 13 Seconds to Win Their First Ever Bowl Victory

What a difference a second makes. With 14 seconds left, the Utah State Aggies led 23-17 in the Potato Bowl. With 13 seconds left, their game against Ohio was tied at 23. When Bobcat Matt Weller’s extra point cleared the uprights, Ohio won its first ever bowl victory, and notched its first 10-win season in 43 years (1968).

Ohio QB Tyler Tettleton led the Bobcats final drive, and scored on a 1-yard run. Tettleton went 19-for-26 (73%) for 220 yards and 2 touchdowns. Utah State had more offense (441 to 345 yards) and a whopping 345 yards rushing to match Ohio’s total output, but Ohio showed why the Bobcats are 10-4 on the season and Utah State is 7-6. Utah State, favored by 2, lost by 1.

New Mexico Bowl:

Temple Uses Rushing Offense and Meddling Defense to Rout Wyoming, 37-15

The Temple Owls, who apparently sleep at night with one eye open, picked off Wyoming quarterback Brett Smith 3 times. And the Wyoming Cowboy defense could not stop Temple’s rushing attack as the Owls piled up 255 yards to beat Wyoming, 37-15, in the New Mexico Bowl, the year’s first bowl game.

The Owl defense held the Cowboy offense to 267 total yards. Temple (9-4), favored by 7, beat Wyoming (8-5) by 22, so you have to believe that Temple boosters were happy with the victory, and the payday.

 

2011 Bowl Game Schedule

Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

You are bright enough. You figure it out. There are 120 major college football teams, and 35 bowl games this year. That means 70 teams will play in bowl games, 13 of which DO NOT even have winning records.

That’s right. Marshall, Arizona State, Purdue, Iowa State, Wake Forest, Mississippi State, Texas A&M, Northwestern, Vanderbilt, Illinois, Ohio State, Florida and Pittsburgh all have 6-6 regular season marks. Not to mention the UCLA Bruins, who have a losing 6-7 record.

It used to be that you could not go to a bowl game if you did not have a winning record (at least 7 wins in 12 games). But greed spawned so many bowl games that there were not enough teams with winning records, so the NCAA standard was lowered to just 6 wins.

The result has been far too many bowl games, and too many mediocre bowl games.

I will be watching exactly 5 bowl games from start to finish—Washington and Baylor, Michigan State and Georgia, Oregon and Wisconsin, Oklahoma State and Stanford, and LSU and Alabama.

If Michigan State is out of it after the first half against Georgia, I will turn off the game.

That said, here is the 2011 Bowl Game Schedule:

Saturday, December 17:

Wyoming (8-4) and Temple (8-4) in the New Mexico Bowl with Temple favored by 7.

Utah State (7-5) and Ohio (9-4) in the Famous Idaho Potato Bowl with Utah State favored by 2.

Louisiana-Lafayette (8-4) and San Diego State (8-4) in the New Orleans Bowl with San Diego State favored by 4.5.

Tuesday, December 20:

Marshall (6-6) and Florida International (8-4) in the Beef O’Brady’s Bowl with Florida International favored by 4.

Wednesday, December 21:

Texas Christian (10-2) and Louisiana Tech (8-4) in the Poinsettia Bowl with TCU favored by 10.5.

Thursday, December 22:

Boise State (11-1) and Arizona State (6-6) in the Maaco Bowl with Boise State favored by 14.

Saturday, December 24, Christmas Eve:

Southern Mississippi (11-2) and Nevada (7-5) in the Hawaii Bowl with Southern Mississippi favored by 6.5.

Monday, December 26:

North Carolina (7-5) and Missouri (7-5) in the Independence Bowl with Missouri favored by 5.

Tuesday, December 27:

Western Michigan (7-5) and Purdue (6-6) in the Little Caesars Bowl with Purdue favored by 2.

North Carolina State (7-5) and Louisville (7-5) in the Belk Bowl with North Carolina State favored by 3.

Wednesday, December 28:

Air Force (7-5) and Toledo (8-4) in the Military Bowl with Air Force favored by 3.

California (7-5) and Texas (7-5) in the Holiday Bowl with Texas favored by 3.

Thursday, December 29:

Florida State (8-4) and Notre Dame (8-4) in the Champs Sports Bowl with Florida State favored by 3.

Washington (7-5) and Baylor (9-3) in the Alamo Bowl with Baylor favored by 9.

Friday, December 30:

Brigham Young (9-3) and Tulsa (8-4) in the Armed Forces Bowl with Brigham Young favored by 3.

Rutgers (8-4) and Iowa State (6-6) in the Pinstripe Bowl with Rutgers favored by 2.

Wake Forest (6-6) and Mississippi State (6-6) in the Music City Bowl with Mississippi State favored by 7.

Oklahoma (9-3) and Iowa (7-5) in the Insight Bowl with Oklahoma favored by 14.

Saturday, December 31, New Year’s Eve:

Texas A&M (6-6) and Northwestern (6-6) in the Meineke Car Care Bowl with Texas A&M favored by 10.

Utah (7-5) and Georgia Tech (8-4) in the Sun Bowl with Georgia Tech favored by 3.5

Cincinnati (9-3) and Vanderbilt (6-6) in the Liberty Bowl with Vanderbilt favored by 3.

UCLA (6-7) and Illinois (6-6) in the Fight Hunger Bowl with Illinois favored by 3.

Virginia (8-4) and Auburn (7-5) in the Chick-fil-A Bowl with Auburn favored by 1.5.

Monday, January 2:

Houston (12-1) and Penn State (9-3) in the TicketCity Bowl with Houston favored by 6.

Michigan State (10-3) and Georgia (10-3) in the Outback Bowl with Georgia favored by 3.

Nebraska (9-3) and South Carolina (10-2) in the Capital One Bowl with South Carolina favored by 3.

Ohio State (6-6) and Florida (6-6) in the Gator Bowl with Florida favored by 2.

Oregon (11-2) and Wisconsin (11-2) in the Rose Bowl with Oregon favored by 6.

Oklahoma State (11-1) and Stanford (11-1) in the Fiesta Bowl with Oklahoma State favored by 3.5.

Tuesday, January 3:

Michigan (10-2) and Virginia Tech (11-2) in the Sugar Bowl with Michigan favored by 3.

Wednesday, January 4:

Clemson (10-3) and West Virginia (9-3) in the Orange Bowl with Clemson favored by 3.5.

Friday, January 6:

Arkansas (10-2) and Kansas State (10-2) in the Cotton Bowl with Arkansas favored by 7.5.

Saturday, January 7:

Southern Methodist (7-5) and Pittsburgh (6-6) in the BBVA Compass Bowl with Pittsburgh favored by 4.5.

Sunday, January 8:

Arkansas State (10-2) and Northern Illinois (10-3) in the GoDaddy.com Bowl with Arkansas State favored by 1.5.

Monday, January 9, the National Championship Game:

Louisiana State (13-0) and Alabama (11-1) with the betting line even, the only 1 of 35 bowl games with the betting line even.

I will be covering all 35 bowl games, but I will only be watching 5 of them start to finish, and I will not watch the Michigan State game after halftime IF the Spartans are out of it at that point in time.

 

Ed Bagley’s Top 25 Poll – Week 14
 
Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

Regular season play in major college football ended this week with 6 conference champions taking their rightful place following playoff games. The winners included LSU in the SEC, Wisconsin in the Big Ten, Clemson in the ACC, Oregon in the Pac-12, Southern Mississippi in the C-USA, and Northern Illinois in the MAC.

Here is my Top 25 for regular season play. A final poll for the 2011 season will be done following completion of the bowl games, and the national championship game between LSU and Alabama.

1)  LSU (13-0) – Did you know that LSU is the only team in America to beat 5 teams ranked in the current AP Top 25 Poll by sports writers and broadcasters? On their way to the only perfect season record, the Tigers have beaten #23 West Virginia, #18 Georgia, and 3 of the top 7 seven teams–#7 Arkansas, #6 Oregon and #2 Alabama. LSU won the SEC championship. Excluding their 9-6 win over Alabama, the Tigers had an average victory margin of 30 points in their other 12 games, and logged 5 wins by 30+ and 2 by 40+. Now you know why I have had LSU ranked #1 in my poll for the ENTIRE season.

2)  Alabama (11-1) – Only loss was to LSU 9-6 in overtime. Beat 2 Top 25 teams–#24 Penn State and #7 Arkansas. The Crimson Tide victory margin in their 11 wins was 30, and they logged 3 wins by 40+ and 2 by 30+. Now you know why I have had Alabama ranked #2 in my poll for the ENTIRE season.

3)  Wisconsin (11-2) – What? You thought my #3 would be Oklahoma State, Stanford, Southern California, Oregon, Arkansas or Boise State? The Badgers are only 1 of 2 teams to beat 3 Top 25 teams–#24 Penn State, #21 Nebraska and #12 Michigan State. The Badgers won the first ever Big Ten championship. They are a bruising, physical, running team. Just as tough as Michigan State, but one play better when it really counted.

4)  Oklahoma State (11-1) – The exciting and electric Cowboys are the other team to beat 3 Top 25 competitors–#19 Oklahoma, #15 Baylor and #11 Kansas State. They have a porous defense, but sure are fun to watch on the offense.

5)  Michigan State (10-3) – One of 6 teams with at least 2 wins over Top 25 schools–#13 Michigan and #9 Wisconsin. One of the better defensive teams in the nation.

6)  Oregon (11-2) – Knocked off #4 Stanford. Won first ever Pac-12 championship. The Ducks no-huddle, spread option offense is a killer for speed and scoring efficiency. Their defense is actually better this year than last.

7)  Stanford (11-1) – Took care of #5 USC, and looking to play better competition.

8)  Southern California (10-2) – A little late to the party, but did finish strong with an upset of #6 Oregon, not an easy task on any Saturday.

9)  Arkansas (10-2) – Took care of #10 South Carolina, and competes in the same SEC West Division as LSU, Alabama and Auburn, and that’s NOT an easy row to hoe. Only losses were to #1 LSU and #2 Alabama.

10)  Clemson (10-3) – Beat #25 Florida State and #17 Virginia Tech. Won the ACC championship.

11)  Nebraska (9-3) – Managed to beat #24 Penn State and #12 Michigan State, both good defensive teams.

12)  Baylor (9-3) – Defeated #19 Oklahoma and #16 Texas Christian.

13) Oklahoma (9-3) – Got thumped by Okie-State in an embarrassing loss, but took down #25 Florida State and #11 Kansas State. So why #13 for Oklahoma? Well, because the Sooners are among only 6 teams to gain 2 wins over Top 25 teams. Only Wisconsin and Okie-State had 3 wins. No one had 4 victories over Top 25 teams, and LSU had FIVE.

The next 8 teams all beat only 1 Top 25 team.

14)  Michigan (10-2)  – Beat #21 Nebraska. The Wolverines are now winning again.

15)  Kansas State (10-2) – Beat #15 Baylor.

16)  South Carolina (10-2) – Beat #18 Georgia.

17)  Texas Christian (10-2) – Upset #8 Boise State.

18)  Boise State (11-1) – Beat #18 Georgia.

19)  Southern Mississippi (11-2) – Beat #20 Houston. This was not an upset. They were better than Houston before they played the Cougars.

20)  Notre Dame (8-4) – Upset #12 Michigan State.

21)  Georgia Tech (8-4) – Upset #14 Clemson.

Did you know that such hyped teams as Virginia Tech, Georgia, Houston, West Virginia, Penn State and Florida State DID NOT beat a single Top 25 team. Yeah, that’s why most Top 25 polls factor in popularity rather than performance on the field.

I reward great teams that beat other good to great teams, and good teams who beat higher-ranked opponents that they should not—that’s why Notre Dame and Georgia Tech are IN my poll, they did something that a bunch of other teams didn’t. Despite the hype, why reward non-performance?

22)  Georgia (10-3) – Not a world beater, but could beat all of the teams below.

23)  Penn State (9-3) – Only losses were to Alabama, Nebraska and Wisconsin. Many other teams could only wish that they lost to these 3 teams rather than some other lesser light. Say a prayer for the non-football victims at Happy Valley, and hope that the Penn State administrators and coaches show some compassion and better judgment in their future affairs. Kudos to the players who played through the tragedy that was no fault of their own.

24)  Houston (12-1) – The Cougars are not nearly as good as their record would indicate. It makes me tired just listening to who they DIDN’T play to get 12 wins.

25)  Iowa State (6-6) – Upset #3 Oklahoma State, and played the 2nd toughest schedule in the country. I respect that MORE than the effort put forth by West Virginia, Florida State or Cincinnati, all of whom could not beat even one Top 25 team.

Let the bowl games begin, and let’s see who will still be standing tall, or not at all. 

 

College Football Wrap-Up – Week 14

Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

When push came to shove in this year’s conference championship playoffs, the winners stepped up—LSU in the SEC, Wisconsin in the Big Ten, Clemson in the ACC, Oregon in the Pac-12, Southern Mississippi in the C-USA, and Northern Illinois in the MAC.

The nation’s only unbeaten team, #1 LSU (13-0), was favored by 14 at home over #12 Georgia (10-3) for the Southeastern Conference title, and the Tigers delivered big time, taking the Bulldogs for a long, lonely walk in the woods while putting them to rest, 42-10.

The Bulldogs had upset on their mind, sneaking off to a quick 10-0 lead, but the Tigers introduced the Bulldogs to the “Honey Badger” in the woods, and the Badger was having none of it.

Tyrann Mathieu (aka the Honey Badger) went the distance on a 62-yard punt return before halftime to remind Georgia how LSU got to be 12-0 before starting the game.

Then the Honey Badger set up another score by recovering a fumble, and put the game away with another 47-yard whirling dervish punt return in the 3rd quarter that had 11 defenders trying to stop him, and set up a short yardage touchdown by Kenny Hilliard, giving LSU a 21-10 margin.

Make no mistake, Georgia came to play. The Bulldogs held LSU to only 12 yards on offense and no first downs in the 1st half. But when the Honey Badger went to work, LSU reeled off 42 unanswered points.

It was only a week ago that LSU spotted #6 Arkansas an early 14-zip lead, and then outscored the Razorbacks 41-3 to win, 41-17. One mark of a championship team is that they can play defense. Another mark is they can come from behind to beat a #6 or #12 team.

If Tyrann Mathieu, only a sophomore, was not the MVP of the SEC championship game, he should have been.

The Honey Badger, who plays defense, has scored 4 touchdowns this season—2 on returns, and 2 from his cornerback position. He’s forced 6 fumbles, picked off 2 passes, and is one of the top tacklers on one of the nation’s top defenses. If he stays healthy, Tyrann Mathieu will most definitely be playing on Sundays in the NFL.

LSU’s outstanding freshman runner, Kenny Hilliard, made it a double whammy for the Tigers. He picked up 72 yards in 8 carries (9.0 YPC) and scored 3 touchdowns, 2 running and 1 receiving.

LSU will now play a return match with Alabama for the national championship.

# 15 Wisconsin got the late touchdown it needed, the late stop in needed, and the big break in needed to top #11 Michigan State and win the first ever Big Ten playoff title, 42-39.

It was sweet revenge for the Badgers (no relation to the Honey Badger), who lost to Michigan State during the regular season on a deflected Hail Mary pass, 37-31.

This time, it was Wisconsin’s turn when Russell Wilson scrambled out of the pocket on a 4th-and-6 play to find Jeff Duckworth, launching a perfect pass to Duckworth who made a leaping catch to set up the go-ahead, 7-yard TD run by Montee Ball with 3:45 left in the game.

Michigan State could have won the game when Keshawn Martin nearly returned a Wisconsin punt for a TD, but it was called back because Isaiah Lewis hit punter Brad Nortman, and the 5-yard penalty gave Wisconsin a gift first down that allowed the Badgers to run out the clock as the Spartans were out of timeouts.

Ball was sensational in the victory, rushing for 137 yards on 27 carries (5.1 YPC) and scoring 3 touchdowns on the ground and 1 in the air. Wilson, one of the nation’s best quarterbacks, went 17-of-24 (71%) for 187 yards and 3 touchdowns with no interceptions.

Michigan State’s B.J. Cunningham caught 5 passes for 115 yards (23.0 YPC) and 3 touchdowns. Le’Veon Bell added 106 yards on 18 carries (5.89 YPC), but it was the Badgers moment in the sun.

Wisconsin will now play Oregon in the BCS Rose Bowl.

The #8 Oregon Ducks (11-2) took out an unranked 6-7 UCLA team, 49-31, to win the first ever Pacific 12 playoff title and Oregon’s 3rd straight Pac-12 title. UCLA got into the title game because #9 Southern California (10-2) was ineligible to compete due to NCAA sanctions.

Junior LaMichael James, the nation’s leading rusher, made short work of the Bruins, rushing for 219 yards on 25 carries (8.8 YPC) and scoring 3 touchdowns, giving him 52 for his career, and a tie for 2nd most Pac-12 career touchdowns with USC’s LenDale White.

Oregon went to the Rose Bowl after the 2009 regular season and lost to Ohio State in coach Chip Kelly’s first season. Last year the Ducks lost to Auburn in the national championship game. Had the Ducks not lost 38-35 to Southern Cal earlier in the year, they might well have been in the national championship game this year.

The #5 Virginia Tech Hokies were favored by 7 over the #21 Clemson Tigers for the Atlantic Coast Conference title, but the Tigers came up big, upsetting Virginia Tech in a rout, 38-10. It was the Tigers first 10-win season since 1990, and their first BCS Orange Bowl berth since 1981, the year they won their only national title.

Sophomore quarterback Tajh Boyd led the way, completing 20 of 29 passes (69%) for 240 yards and 3 touchdowns. He was the game’s MVP. Boyd came into the game as a question mark, having thrown 7 interceptions and only 4 TDs in his previous 4 games.

The Tigers opened their season at 8-0 and then promptly lost 3 of their next 4 games. A big reason why Clemson beat Virginia Tech was the Tigers held Hokie tailback David Wilson, the ACC’s player of the year, to 32 yards on 11 carries.

By winning the ACC title game, Clemson became the only team to beat Virginia Tech (now 11-2) twice in the same season.

The #24 Southern Mississippi Golden Eagles (11-2) ruined the #7 Houston Cougars (12-1) perfect season and BCS hopes by upsetting Houston, 49-28, to claim the Conference USA championship.

A lot of Cougar fans were surprised by this event, but Golden Eagle QB Austin Davis was not one of them. Davis carved up the deficient Houston defense by slinging 4 touchdown passes for 14, 16, 69 and 61 yards. Case Keenum was not a factor.

Houston came into the game leading the nation in passing offense (443+ Yards Per Game), total offense (599 YPG), and scoring offense (50+ PPG). Big whoop.
There are probably a dozen quarterbacks that could put up Keenum’s numbers if they played the crummy teams he faced this season.

Entering the championship game, Houston and Keenum faced such illustrious passing defenses as Tulsa (ranked 118th among 120 major college teams), UAB (ranked 114th), North Texas (113th), Rice (111th), Marshall (100th), Louisiana Tech (94th), UTEP (92nd) and Tulane (85th). It is easier when you have all day to throw and do it against a lousy pass defense.

Southern Mississippi (ranked 23rd nationally) was the first decent pass defense Houston and Keenum faced all season. It’s a wonder that Houston did not get beat even worse than they did.

If you want a good belly laugh, try this on for size—Houston was favored in this game by 14.5 and lost by 21. That’s a 35+ point swing. The AP Top 25 Poll had Houston ranked at 7th in the nation last week.

Houston would have been exposed much earlier in the year if the Cougars actually played a decent team on its way to a 12-0 mark before getting found out. Kudos to the Southern Mississippi Golden Eagles, who not only deserved to win, but did so in such an outstanding way.

Unranked Ohio (9-4) found out who was the best in the Mid American Conference as the unranked Northern Illinois Huskies (10-3) beat the Bobcats, 23-20, to claim their first MAC championship since 1983.

Chandler Harnish led the Huskies, who were down 20-0 at the half, by throwing 3 second half touchdowns. Mathew Sims kicked a 33-yard field goal on the final play to cap the furious rally. The Huskies won by 3 rather than 4 points because one of their extra point kicks missed.

The victory was ever so sweet for Northern Illinois as the Huskies had lost championship games in the last minute to Miami of Ohio in 2010, and to Akron in 2005. Last year’s defeat was crushing as Miami of Ohio converted on a 4th-and-20 before scoring the winning touchdown.

Ohio has not won a MAC title since 1968, but is still 1 of 6 teams from the C-USA that are bowl eligible.  
   
Here is how the other AP Top 25 teams fared in college football’s 14th week that ended regular season play:

#3 Oklahoma State (11-1) at home ran away from the #13 ranked, 9-3 Oklahoma Sooners, 44-10, to win their first outright Big 12 title since 1948. Oklahoma had dominated this series for years, even when the Sooners were not a top-tier team.

Two years ago, the Sooners cost  Oklahoma State a BCS at-large berth, and last year the Sooners stole Oklahoma State’s chance at a conference title. But not this year.

The much-maligned Cowboy defense (they rank 107th among 120 major teams) finally played like a better defense.

Brodrick Brown outfought Jaz Reynolds to pick off Landry Jones’ pass in the end zone and prevent a Sooner score. Alex Elkins stripped the ball from Landry on a sack to set up a TD for the Cowboys. Jamie Blatnick picked up a fumble and rambled 59 yards to the 1-yard line to give the Cowboys another score. And Richetti Jones returned a fumble 5 yards for a score.

On the offensive side of the ball, Cowboy Joe Randle rambled for 151 yards on 19 carries (7.9 YPC) and scored twice. It was quite a day for the Cowboys, who are clearly the best team in Oklahoma this year.

The loss by Oklahoma was its most lopsided since losing the 2005 Orange Bowl to Southern California.

#9 Boise State (11-1) at home made road kill out of the unranked 1-11 New Mexico Lobos, shutting them out 45-zip.

#16 Kansas State (10-2) at home beat the unranked 6-6 Iowa State Cyclones by a touchdown, 30-23.

#18 Texas Christian (10-2) at home ripped apart the unranked 2-10 UNLV Rebels, 56-9.

#19 Baylor (9-3) at home easily beat the unranked 7-6 Texas Longhorns, 48-24.

#22 West Virginia (9-3) OTR just beat the unranked 5-7 South Florida Bulls by a field goal, 30-27.

Match-ups for the 2011 bowl season will be announced on Monday (12-5).

 

College Football’s Week 14 Preview

Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

So it has come down to this: 12 teams will play but only 6 conference championships are available as major college football enters its 14th week of play, and bowl game selections will follow on Monday, Dec. 5.

Here are the teams looking for titles and BCS bowl bids by order of importance:

Southeastern Conference (SEC)
#1 LSU (12-0) West Division Champion vs. #12 Georgia (10-2) East Division Champion at the Georgia Dome in Atlanta, GA on Saturday.

Big Ten Conference (Big Ten)
#11 Michigan State (10-2) Legends Division Champion vs. #15 Wisconsin (10-2) Leaders Division Champion at Lucas Oil Stadium in Indianapolis, IN on Saturday.

Atlantic Coast Conference (ACC)
#5 Virginia Tech (11-1) Coastal Division Champion vs. #21 Clemson (9-3) Atlantic Division Champion at Bank of America Stadium in Charlotte, NC on Saturday.

Pacific 12 Conference (Pac-12)
#8 Oregon (10-2) North Division Champion vs. Unranked UCLA (6-6) South Division Champion at Autzen Stadium in Eugene, OR on Friday. #9 Southern California (10-2) is really the South Division Champion but cannot play for the title or compete in a bowl game this year because of NCAA sanctions, so UCLA becomes the default champion. Oregon will have no mercy on a 6-6 UCLA team.

Conference USA (C-USA)
#6 Houston (12-0) West Division Champion vs. #23 Southern Mississippi (10-2) East Division Champion at Robertson Stadium in Houston, TX on Saturday.

Mid American Conference (MAC)
Unranked Ohio (9-3) East Division Champion vs. Unranked Northern Illinois (9-3) West Division Champion at Ford Field in Detroit, MI on Friday.

Only one other non-conference championship game is of importance–#13 Oklahoma (9-2) travels to #3 Oklahoma State (10-1) on Saturday to see who will prevail in the “Dust Bowl” for Okie-State.

 

Ed Bagley’s Top 25 Poll – Week 13
 
Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

For the first time in 13 weeks, there were no surprises or upsets this week, making at least my first 14 picks easier.

1)  LSU (12-0) – Ripped #3 Arkansas 41-17 to end the regular season unbeaten. Plays Georgia in the SEC title game this week. It’s doubtful that the Bulldogs can hang with the Tigers for 60 minutes. I’d put my money on LSU to figure out how to win, and move on.

2)  Alabama (11-1) – Breezed by Auburn 42-14, and is making its case to play LSU for all the marbles.

3)  Oregon (10-2) – Took down Oregon State 49-21 in The Civil War. Only losses were to LSU by 13 and Southern Cal by 3. Big clue: No one wants to play Southern Cal right now.

4)  Stanford (11-1) – Beat Notre Dame 28-14. Only loss was to Oregon.

5)  Southern California (10-2) – Could beat both Oklahoma State and Virginia Tech next week, and end the year at 12-2. Way underrated at this point in the season.

6)  Oklahoma State (11-1) – Lost to a 6-5 Iowa State team. Am still trying to figure out who they have beaten that is a big deal. Lack of Cowboy defense is troubling. Think they will lose again to Oklahoma Saturday, and Oklahoma isn’t THAT good either.

7)  Virginia Tech (11-1) – Knocked off Virginia 38-zip. That said, the ACC is hardly the SEC, and the Hokies may find that out in their bowl game.

8)  Michigan State (10-2) – Just beat Northwestern 31-17 to finish the regular season. Now plays Wisconsin for the Big Ten title, and possible automatic BCS bowl berth. Get over my pick. I understand Houston is undefeated and Boise State is 10-1. I would like to see either of them beat Ohio State, Michigan and Wisconsin in 3 consecutive weeks. Call me up when either of them actually get into a league where they have to play real competition continually.

9)  Arkansas (10-2) – Was not a factor against LSU, and also lost to Alabama. Not too shabby when you lose to the current #1 and #2 teams in the country. It sure beats losing to Iowa State, Clemson, Texas Tech or Baylor. Let’s see if the Razorbacks can bounce back in their bowl game.

10)  South Carolina (10-2) – Thumped Clemson 34-13. Only losses were to Auburn and Arkansas. Beat Georgia in an away game. Will have a chance to gain more credence with a big bowl win.

11)  Georgia (10-2) – Dusted off Georgia Tech 31-17. Only losses were to Boise State and South Carolina in its first two games of the year, and now has won 10 straight, and feeling like they can put the hurt on LSU in the SEC title game. Well, Bulldogs, give it your best shot.

12)  Oklahoma (9-2) – Beat an Iowa State team that Oklahoma State could not, and now travels to Okie-State for a final game showdown for bragging rights in the Dust Bowl. I’m counting on Oklahoma to beat Oklahoma State, that ‘s how little I like the Cowboys’ porous defense.

13)  Michigan (10-2) – Finally beat Ohio State for the first time in 8 years. Any team that can beat Notre Dame, Iowa, Nebraska and Ohio State in the same year has to be pretty good.

14)  Wisconsin (10-2) – Crushed Penn State 45-7 in final regular season game. Faces Michigan State for the first, expanded Big Ten title. Seeks major revenge after losing to Michigan State 37-31 earlier in the season.

15)  Boise State (10-1) – Beat Wyoming 36-14 and keeps acting like it’s a big deal. Faces a 1-10 New Mexico team next. Good grief, will it ever end? The Broncos are the top contender for the Purification Bowl to be held at Barium, Utah.

16)  Houston (12-0) – Nation’s only other unbeaten team took down Tulsa 48-16. If there are players on a team that have more fun than the Cougars, I would like to know where they are. Houston has built its unbeaten record by playing in the West Division of Conference USA, and facing teams with a combined losing record of 61-82 (a 42% win percentage).

Houston leads the nation in passing offense, total offense and scoring offense, which sounds really impressive. When you realize that star QB Case Keenum is ranked #3 nationally in passing efficiency, and examine who he has faced, it looks a lot less impressive. Keenum has completed 73% of his passes for 4,726 yards with 43 touchdowns and only 3 interceptions.

And, as Paul Harvey would say, here’s the rest of the story: Keenum has faced such outstanding pass defense teams as Tulsa (ranked 118th among 120 major college teams), UAB (ranked 114th), North Texas (113th), Rice (111th), Marshall (100th), Louisiana Tech (94th), UTEP (92nd) and Tulane (85th). It is easier when you have all day to throw and do it against a lousy pass defense.

Does the Boise State AD lie awake at night figuring out who has the worst pass protection in the nation? Nah, they just play lame competition. And you wonder why I rank Houston at 16th?

After that research, and with the AP Top 25 Poll’s prestigious sportswriters and broadcasters ranking Houston #7 this week, I simply have to quit this nonsense at #16 Houston. Houston is certainly an exciting but modest little team, with much to be modest about.

There are probably a dozen other teams that could be ranked at 17th through #25 in this poll, but really, they are out in left field at this point in the season. Let’s see who wins the conference title games this weekend. It’s time for double shots of Jameson Irish whiskey.

 

College Football Wrap-Up – Week 13

Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

In college football’s climactic 13th week, LSU beat Arkansas in the big game, Alabama took care of Auburn, and there were NO upsets of ranked teams. A strange silence has now fallen over the voters who must decide who will play in the national championship game.

Should Alabama be given a second shot at LSU this season? The new BCS rankings have LSU at #1 and Alabama #2. Or should LSU play another opponent? That assumes that LSU beats Georgia in this week’s SEC championship game.

Waiting in the wings are three 1-loss teams–#3 Oklahoma State, #4 Stanford and #5 Virginia Tech. None of these 3 possible challengers have anything to get uppity about.

Virginia Tech, the really weak sister, was beaten 23-3 by Clemson, and would have lost more games had they not played such a weak schedule (60th toughest among 120 major teams—nothing to email home to mom about).

Stanford looked pretty darn good until they ran into Oregon and lost 53-30, and the score made the game look closer than it was.

Oklahoma State has played the 8th toughest schedule, but was beaten on-the-road (OTR) 37-31 in double overtime by a 6-5 Iowa State team. The Cowboys were upset because they do not have a defense worth talking about. Oklahoma State hosts the Oklahoma Sooners Saturday and could be beaten again.

The smart money says LSU wins the SEC title and is all but a lock for the national championship game. The #1 Tigers (12-0) certainly looked awesome in dismantling #3 Arkansas (10-2) over the weekend. 

The Razorbacks jumped out to a 14-0 lead by scoring on a long drive to end the 1st quarter, and then scored again on LSU’s next possession when Alonzo Highsmith recovered a Michael Floyd fumble and returned it 47 yards.

LSU then got down to business by running off 41 points while holding Arkansas to a field goal the rest of the way to win, 41-17. A 92-yard punt return by Tyrann Mathieu provided a big lift for the Tigers, tying it up at 14-all.

The Tigers would eventually rush for 286 yards, sack Auburn’s Tyler Wilson 5 times and intercept him once, and Mathieu would also force 2 fumbles with strips. Mathieu now has 6 forced fumbles for the season.

The win for LSU gave the Tigers their first 12-0 regular season record ever. They will play #13 Georgia (10-2) for the SEC title Saturday.

Here’s how the rest of the college football world looked Saturday at midnight:

#2 Alabama (11-1) OTR easily beat Auburn, 42-14, as Crimson Tide running back Trent Richardson rushed for a career-high 203 yards (7.5 yards per carry), and AJ McCarron threw 3 first-half touchdown passes.

#4 Stanford (11-1) at home took down #22 Notre Dame (8-4), 28-14, as The Cardinal QB Andrew Luck set the school record for the most career touchdown passes (80 in 3 years), and most in a single season (35). The old career record was held by John Elway with 77 career TDs. The win could give Stanford an at-large BCS bid for the second consecutive year.

#5 Oklahoma State (10-1) was idle.

#6 Virginia Tech (11-1) OTR blanked #24 Virginia (8-4), 38-zip, and will play Clemson (9-3) for the Atlantic Coast Conference championship Saturday. Logan Thomas threw for 2 touchdowns and ran for another, and David Wilson scored on 27 and 38-yard runs.

#7 Boise State (10-1) at home beat Wyoming, 36-14. Big deal. The Broncos have played the 51st toughest schedule, and will end their season hosting a 1-10 New Mexico team. 

#8 Houston (12-0) ripped Tulsa, 48-16, to end its regular season unbeaten. For the record, the Cougars play in Conference USA, and have played a pathetic strength of schedule, ranking 111th among 120 major college teams. What is even more stupid, arcane and bovine is that the BCS currently has Houston ranked #6.

#9 Oregon (10-2) put a whipping on Oregon State, 49-21, as LaMichael James, the nation’s leading rusher, ran for 142 yards before leaving the game with an apparent left elbow injury. James was already wearing a brace on his right elbow, which he dislocated 7 weeks ago. Darron Thomas threw for 305 yards and 4 touchdowns against the Beavers. The Ducks will now host UCLA on Friday night with a chance to win their 3rd straight conference title, and a spot in the Rose Bowl.

#10 Southern California (10-2) at home put a 50-0 beating on UCLA (6-6) that the Bruins will not soon forget. Bruin coach Rick Neuheisel will now face Oregon for the Pacific 12 title because USC is ineligible for the Pac-12 title and a bowl game due to NCAA sanctions. The last time UCLA played Oregon, the Bruins were hammered, 60-13. Guest what? UCLA and Neuheisel are about to be hammered . . . again.

#11 Michigan State (10-2) OTR blew past Northwestern, 31-17, as Kirk Cousins threw 2 touchdown passes to become Michigan State’s all-time career leader for TD passes with 62, breaking Jeff Smoker’s school record of 61 career TDs. Cousins is 21-4 as a starter the last 2 seasons. The Spartans league-best defense added 6 sacks during the win.

#12 Oklahoma (9-2) at home beat Iowa State (6-5), 26-6. Oklahoma State (10-1) lost to Iowa State 37-31 in double overtime last week. So how good is Okie-State? You will not have to wait long to find out as its Oklahoma at Oklahoma State Saturday.

#13 Georgia (10-2) OTR kept #25 Georgia Tech (8-4) at bay, winning 31-17 as Bulldog Aaron Murray threw 4 TD passes to extend Georgia’s win streak to 10 after losing its first 2 games of the season. The Bulldogs now face LSU for the SEC title Saturday.

#14 South Carolina (10-2) blasted #18 Clemson (9-3), 34-13, as Conner Shaw threw 3 TD passes and ran for another while the Gamecocks notched their first 10-win season in 27 years, and only its second 10-win season in 118 years. South Carolina’s defense held Clemson’s early season, high-octane offense to 153 yards. Clemson started the season at 8-0 and now has lost 3 of its last 4 games, and now faces Virginia Tech for the ACC title. The Gamecocks lost their superstar runner Marcus Lattimore for the season in their 7th-week, 14-12 win over Mississippi State—a testimony to the Gamecocks hanging tough.

#15 Wisconsin (10-2) at home made short work of #20 Penn State (9-3), beating the Nittany Lions senseless, 45-7, as Montee Ball scored 4 rushing touchdowns to give him 34 for the season. Ball picked up 156 yards on 25 carries (6.2 YPC). Ball is chasing Barry Sanders’ NCAA record of 39 for Oklahoma State set in 11 games during the 1988 season. Let it be said: There will never be another runner as exciting as Barry Sanders, although the great open field runner Gayle Sayers was close. By winning, Wisconsin now has as shot at Michigan State for the Big Ten title, and a possible spot in the Rose Bowl.

#16 Kansas State (9-2) was idle.

#17 Michigan (10-2) at home beat unranked Ohio State (6-6), 40-34, for the first time in more than 2,900 days—the Wolverine win snapped a 7-year losing streak to the Buckeyes. Michigan’s Danard Robinson had quite the game—going 14-for-17 (82%) for 167 yards and 3 touchdown passes, and running 26 times for 170 yards (6.54 YPC) and 2 touchdowns.

#19 Texas Christian (9-2) was idle.

#21 Baylor (8-3) at home beat Texas Tech, 66-42.

#22 Nebraska (9-3) at home beat Iowa, 20-7.

Here are the winners among unranked teams playing in-state rivalry games:

Florida State (8-4) over Florida, 21-7 – Welcome to the head coaching ranks, Will Muschamp.

Mississippi State (6-6) over Mississippi, 31-3 – Ole Miss has become Sudden Miss.

North Carolina (7-5) over Duke, 37-21 – The Blue Devils were 3-2 in their first 5 games, but will have to settle their differences with the Tar Heels on the basketball court.

Ohio (9-3) over Miami of Ohio, 21-14 – Ohio coach Frank Solich just won his 3rd Mid-American Conference Division title. In 19 years as an assistant at Nebraska, he helped the Cornhuskers win 3 national championships and 11 conference titles. As a head coach at Nebraska, Solich was 59-19, and had one 3-year stretch at 33-5 before he was drop-kicked out of Nebraska by a new athletic director. Such is coaching.

Purdue (6-6) over Indiana, 33-25 – It is hard to tell who is worse, 1-11 Indiana or 0-12 Tuba City, Montana.
 
San Jose State (5-7) over Fresno State, 27-24 – There was a time when major college teams did not want to play mid-major Fresno State.

Southern Methodist (7-5) over Rice, 27-24 – SMU coach June Jones beat 3 Texas teams—UTEP, TCU and Rice—but lost to 2 others—Texas A&M and Houston. He has yet to get the Mustangs to a 9-win season with his run and shoot offense.

Texas (7-4) over Texas A&M, 27-25 – It’s been tough for the Longhorns since defensive coordinator Will Muschamp left to coach the Florida Gators. Will the glory years return for Texas?

Washington (7-5) over Washington State, 38-21 – Sophomore Keith Price threw 3 touchdown passes to become Washington’s all-time single-season leader with 29 for the year, breaking Cody Pickett’s school record of 28 in a season. He was 21-of-29 (72%) for 291 yards in the victory. The win was the 3rd straight over Washington State for coach Steve Sarkisian and his staff, and may have cost Cougar coach Paul Wulff his job—there is rumbling on the Palouse that a change is needed at Wazoo.

 

SEC Showdown Looms Large

Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

Twelve AP Top 25 ranked teams lock horns in major college football’s 13th weekend—none bigger than the #1 LSU Tigers (11-0) who will play host to the #3 Arkansas Razorbacks (10-1) on Friday, with the SEC title playoff on the line, and a chance to compete in the national championship game.

The other critical game Saturday finds #2 Alabama (10-1) at Auburn (7-4).

If things are not confusing enough, cogitate on this:

If both LSU and Alabama win, they will play for the national title, assuming that LSU beats Georgia in the playoff for the SEC title. LSU leads the SEC West Division, and Georgia leads the SEC East Division.

But if Arkansas and Alabama win, resulting in a 3-way tie for first in the SEC West, the Division’s rep in the SEC title game against Georgia Dec. 3 would be determined by the head-to-head result between the top two SEC teams in the BCS standings after this week’s games.

If Alabama and LSU are the top two, LSU goes to the SEC title game. If it’s Arkansas and LSU, then Arkansas would advance. If it’s Alabama and Arkansas, then Alabama goes.

Then it gets really crazy if Georgia wins the SEC title, and goes to the Sugar Bowl, and two other SEC teams are 1-2 in final BCS standings, the league would automatically get 3 teams in BCS games. That’s something that theoretically isn’t supposed to happen and never has. But it could.

Here are some cold, hard facts on the LSU-Arkansas clash:

LSU has played the 25th toughest schedule in the country, Arkansas the 49th toughest.

LSU has the 21st best rushing offense nationally, Arkansas ranks 72nd.

Arkansas has the 10th best passing offense, LSU ranks 103rd.

Arkansas has the 21st best total offense, LSU ranks 75th.

Arkansas has the 13th best scoring offense, LSU is right behind at 14th.

LSU has the 4th best rushing defense, Arkansas ranks 70th.

LSU has the 5th best pass defense, Arkansas ranks 28th.

LSU has the 2nd best total defense, Arkansas ranks 44th.

LSU has the 2nd best scoring defense, Arkansas ranks 30th.

Conclusions based on the performance stats of each team:

LSU relies on its running attack, and a very stout defense. LSU can run, and stop the run. The Tigers can eat clock by running, which keeps the Razorbacks offense off the field, and the LSU defense can better stop Arkansas.

Arkansas is all about its passing attack, and has a better total offense, but is not as good on the defensive side of the ball. Arkansas must score touchdowns, not field goals to stay ahead in this game.

The likely result: It could be close, but LSU wins because a good defense can stop a good offense easier than a good offense can beat a good defense.

The 5 other ranked opponents who square off include:

#4 Stanford (10-1) hosts #22 Notre Dame (8-3).

#6 Virginia Tech (10-1) travels to #24 Virginia (8-3) – The winner will likely play Clemson for the Atlantic Coast title.

#13 Georgia (9-2) travels to #25 Georgia Tech (8-3).

#14 South Carolina (9-2) hosts in-state rival #18 Clemson (9-2).

#15 Wisconsin (9-2) hosts #20 Penn State (9-2) – The winner will play Michigan State in the first two-division playoff for the Big Ten title.

Here’s the rest of the extended, weekend game lineup:

#1 Louisiana State (12-0) at home whipped #3 Arkansas (10-2), 41-17, to end its regular season play with a perfect 12-0 mark. LSU will now face #13 Georgia for the SEC title and, should the Tigers win, they will be in the BCS national championship game.

#2 Alabama (10-1) travels to Auburn (7-4)

#7 Boise State (9-1) hosts Wyoming (7-3)

#8 Houston (12-0) OTR beat Tulsa (8-4), 48-16, on Friday to end its regular season play with a perfect 12-0 mark. Both teams are eligible for and will be in bowl games.

#9 Oregon (9-2) hosts unranked Oregon State (3-8) in The Civil War, a nasty affair that can turn ugly in a hurry.

#10 Southern California (9-2) hosts UCLA (6-5) – If UCLA upsets Southern Cal, the Bruins would face Stanford for the first two-division playoff for the Pacific 12 title. If UCLA loses to Southern Cal and Utah beats Colorado Saturday, then Utah would play Stanford for the title. USC is ineligible for a Pac 12 title and bowl-game appearance this season because of NCAA sanctions.

#11 Michigan State (9-2) travels to Northwestern (6-5)

#12 Oklahoma (8-2) hosts Iowa State (6-4)

#17 Michigan (9-2) hosts Ohio State (6-5)

#21 Baylor (7-3) hosts Texas Tech (5-6)

#22 Nebraska (9-3) at home beat Iowa (7-5), 20-7, on Friday to end its regular season play. Both teams are eligible for and will be in bowl games. 

Three other ranked teams are idle this week–#5 Oklahoma State (10-1), #16 Kansas State (9-2), and #19 Texas Christian (9-2).

Eight other teams face in-state rivals:
 
Texas at Texas A&M

Rice at Southern Methodist

Florida State at Florida

Mississippi at Mississippi State

Washington State at Washington

Duke at North Carolina

San Jose State at Fresno State

Purdue at Indiana

Ed Bagley’s Top 25 Poll – Week 12
 
Copyright © 2011 Ed Bagley

The posturing, arguing, whining and complaining have begun. One unbeaten and three 1-loss teams that were among the top 7 teams vying to get into the BCS championship game lost this past week, proving why they should not be in the title game, and must move aside for a better team.

My first two picks this week represent better teams.

1)  LSU (11-0) – Whipped Old Miss 52-3 while unbeaten Oklahoma State was upset by Iowa State, Oklahoma was upset by Baylor, Oregon was upset by Southern Cal, and Clemson was upset by North Carolina State. It is clear that any of these teams that lost have no business being in the national championship game. 

2)  Alabama (10-1) – Beat AA Georgia Southern 45-21 while #22 Southern Mississippi was upset by UAB, and #23 Florida State was upset by Virginia. Alabama’s ONLY loss was to LSU, 9-6 in overtime. Should the Crimson Tide be in the national championship game against LSU? It sure seems like they are the second best team in the country. All other potential candidates have disappointed after this past weekend.

3)  Arkansas (10-1) – Just beat Mississippi State 44-17, and their only loss was to Alabama. Travels to LSU Saturday in a big SEC showdown game.

4)  Southern California (9-2) – Had a bad loss to Arizona State earlier in the season, and was beaten by Stanford in overtime, but you would not want to play the Trojans at this point in the season. Southern Cal just beat Oregon, 38-35. Oregon scored the last 21 points of the game, but it was not enough to keep the Ducks from losing.

5)  Penn State (9-2) – At least the Nittany Lions have a better defense than Oklahoma State, Virginia Tech, Stanford or Boise State. Only lost to Alabama (like everyone else except LSU), and to Nebraska by a field goal. Travels to Wisconsin this week for a huge Big Ten showdown, and will either win or get beaten badly. We will see. Penn State has had a lot of bad but deserved publicity in the past two weeks, but none of it originates with the Nittany Lion football players.

6)  Michigan State (9-2) – At least the Spartans have a defense. They were beaten badly by Notre Dame and Nebraska, two games they should have won because they have better talent to go with their defense. Coach Mark Dantonio does not realize that he still has some losers on his team that will tolerate losing unnecessarily.

Consider these next 4 teams with one-loss records tied for 7th place.

7)  Stanford (10-1), Oklahoma State (10-1), Virginia Tech (10-1) and Boise State (9-1).

11)  Oregon (9-2) – Might have lost to LSU by 13 and Stanford by 23, but could beat Oklahoma State, Virginia Tech, Boise State, Houston and Oklahoma. Hosts Oregon State this week in the Civil War, perhaps the closest thing to SEC play outside of SEC play.

12) Houston (11-0) – Giving the Cougars some props here. Houston remains the ONLY unbeaten team besides LSU. It is not easy to go undefeated, even against mediocre competition. And really, who is all that better from here on?

Put these next 8 teams at a tie for 13th.

13)  Oklahoma (8-2), Georgia (9-2), South Carolina (9-2), Wisconsin (9-2), Kansas State (9-2), Michigan (9-2), Clemson (9-2), and TCU (9-2). Show me something and you will move up.

Ditto these 5 for 21st.

21)  Baylor (7-3), Nebraska (8-3), Notre Dame (8-3), Virginia (8-3) and Georgia Tech (8-3). Let’s see Notre Dame beat Stanford this weekend, or Virginia beat Virginia Tech, or Georgia Tech beat Georgia.

Here are the two games to watch this week that really fricking matter: Arkansas at LSU, and Alabama at Auburn. If LSU and Alabama win, they should, hands down, play each other again in the national championship game. All other teams bring excuses, but not the performance necessary for a national championship contender—they had their chances and failed. Period.

Let’s face reality—the result of every football game is one of two things, results or excuses. They are also called wins and losses, or I keep my job, or I lose my job.

I’m out of here, time for some Jameson Irish whiskey.

 

Sports Quote of the Day

"If you burn your neighbor's house down, it doesn't make your house look any better." Former Legendary Notre Dame Football Coach Lou Holtz

Ed’s College Football RSS Feed

  Subscribe to my RSS Feed now to keep up with my sharp commentary and analysis of the upcoming 2012 College Football season.

At Quality Resumes by Ed Bagley, I serve to present you at a higher level, readying you for more income, more benefits, more success, more responsibility and a much brighter future. Choose from a variety of resume packages customized to your income range and get a head-start on tomorrow -- today!


Answers to Job Interview Questions
Pick up my booklet "Answers to Job Interview Questions" and Learn How to Respond When It Really Matters With Great Answers to Job Interview Questions.


How to Write a Single Page Resume
If you are going to write your own resume rather than use a pro like me to do it, consider using How to Write a Single Page Resume for your definitive resource starting point.


Ed Bagley's Blog
Ed Bagley's Blog with his news, coverage and commentary as a writer, author, newspaper publisher and book publisher during the past 50 years.


Ed Bagley's Blog Archives
The official archives for my first 971 original articles on 54 different subjects covering 69,000+ pages, including coverage on college football, college basketball, track, distance running, movies, business, marketing, family, relationships, life, faith and politics. Did I forget to mention humor?


Ed Bagley's College Football
Ed Bagley's College Football has a Weekly Wrap-Up of Major 2011 College Action, Complete 2011 Bowl Game Coverage, and the 2011 National Championship Game. Next up is the 2012 Pre-Season Coverage. Go to Ed Bagley's Blog Archives for complete NCAA coverage of the 2007, 2008, 2009 and 2010 seasons.


HyperSmash

Copyright © 2012 Ed Bagley. All Rights Reserved.